MovieChat Forums > Chiefs (1983) Discussion > I just read the novel!

I just read the novel!


I have to say, I can't believe how faithful the mini-series is to the book. As I was reading, I could remember each scene. I suppose there were a couple of city council meetings that may have been cut, but practically every critical scene was in the mini-series (another reason why I don't want to see a shortened version put on DVD).

A few differences:

1) I seem to remember more of Tess Harper's character (Will Henry's wife, Carrie) throughout the series and not so much in the novel.

2) More dialog from Brad Davis' Sonny Butts in the film (like the intense scene with his mother at the dinner table). Usually it's the opposite, but they seemed to enhance the character a bit more. Of course the more sexually explicit moments from the book (most featuring the Sonny Butts chapter) are understandably edited in the mini-series.

3) They changed a couple of names of certain characters. In the book Joshua Cole is actually Willie Cole (considering his best friend is Billy Lee, the Joshua/Billy relationship sounds a little better than the Willy/Billy relationship. Also, Billy Dee Williams' character is called Tyler Watts in the mini-series, but it's Tucker Watts in the book. I'm not sure why they changed that, but either name sounds fine. Finally, they changed Danny Glover's character from Marshall Parker (in the book) to Marshall Peters (in the movie). Very curious, but whatever.

4) I don't want to give away any spoilers but the big revelation between Tyler Watts and Billy Lee DOESN'T EVEN HAPPEN in the novel, if you can believe it. Instead the novel has a much more downbeat ending featuring Hugh Holmes. I have to say while it works for the novel, I'm extremely glad for that modification in the movie.

Anyway, it's a great read! And at least I have that until they finally release the whole darn mini-series on DVD.

reply

4) I don't want to give away any spoilers but the big revelation between Tyler Watts and Billy Lee DOESN'T EVEN HAPPEN in the novel, if you can believe it. Instead the novel has a much more downbeat ending featuring Hugh Holmes. I have to say while it works for the novel, I'm extremely glad for that modification in the movie

Yeah, that was something that always threw me for a loop when I read the book too, it would seem odd that Tucker/Willie [book name] wouldn't reveal who he was after Billy won the governorship.

2) More dialog from Brad Davis' Sonny Butts in the film (like the intense scene with his mother at the dinner table).

First of all, let me say Brad Davis was outstanding in this thing (outstanding actor period, a loss still felt). Another big difference is in the movie Sonny admitted he killed his father [in a staged farming accident] years before at that dinner. Didn't happen in the book. (In fact, I don't recall the book saying how Sonny's dad died [I guess we are to assume alcoholism].)

Another great part of the movie (that didn't happen in the book) is when [a intoxicated] Sonny tells a trooper (after he figured it out about Foxy) to "call his majesty Hugh Holmes!". Great moment.

Man, they've got to put this out on DVD. It's been over 25 years since I've seen it start to finish.







Ignoring: sharon 18, ibestupid, boo321, Generation EX, Lakeishra, allenkr62, Nullifidian

reply

LOL!

I know, I love that "His majesty" moment. I've always remembered that one line, "You CALL his majesty, Hugh Holmes!" more than all others for some reason.

That state trooper must've thought he was looking at a crazy person.

Brad Davis' entire performance is a joy to watch, but that scene with his mother at the dinner table is just incredible. Admitting what he did to his father...then almost laughing when he talks about how he got away with it...then deadly serious again. Just amazing.

reply

Brad Davis' entire performance is a joy to watch, but that scene with his mother at the dinner table is just incredible. Admitting what he did to his father...then almost laughing when he talks about how he got away with it...then deadly serious again. Just amazing.

Yeah, that scene really stood out. Remember how he sort of mocked his mother's defense of him (over the years)? "I don't wanna here no more about 'How noble and full of charity he was.' EVER!"

Difficult movie to forget.




Ignoring: sharon 18, ibestupid, boo321, Generation EX, Lakeishra, allenkr62, Nullifidian

reply

True.

When his mother says, "I wish your father were here to see you."

He says, "You do? I'd prob'ly have to arrest him for drunk and disorderly."

I've got my hands on a kinda bootleg copy of the complete CHIEFS miniseries...it's not the best quality. The audio is especially bad during the Sonny Butts chapter, unfortunately. I'll have to make due until the official DVD release of CHIEFS. I can't wait for that to happen.

reply

This was a very fine novel, and they made a wonderful miniseries of it. The cast was terrific. I know Andy Griffith was originally supposed to play Foxy Funderburke, and he would have been great, but Keith Carradine did a wonderful job. Charlton Heston and Billy Dee Williams were great too. My favorite scene in the novel is where Billy's wife and mother hide behind the trailer and shoot at the KKK. It was hilarious!

reply

Yeah, a great moment from both the book and movie.

reply