MovieChat Forums > The Martian Chronicles (1980) Discussion > Why was Colonel John Wilder ONLY a colon...

Why was Colonel John Wilder ONLY a colonel?


You have to understand military ranks or have been in the military to understand my post. I know that the space agency depicted in THE MARTIAN CHRONICLES was not military but NASA-type. Still, they were using military style ranks, organization, and customs.

My question is that given the tremendous responsibilities Colonel John Wilder carried, that is, the entire, NATO-sponsored Mars exploration program, why was he only a full colonel and not a general? In other countries, a man with John Wilder's huge responsibilities would have been anywhere from a one-star to a three-star general. And one-star general (typically, brigadier general) would have been on the low side. Even in today's USA, such huge program directors are two to three-star generals.

Later on, Colonel John Wilder becomes the de facto governor general of Mars, even though he doesn't have the title. He's still the, 'Mars Program Director'. And he's still a full colonel! At least he should have been rewarded with the rank of brigadier general for his accomplishments. Typically in real life, a man like John Wilder would have risen quickly in rank. He should have been a two-star general. As a governor general he should have had the rank of lieutenant general (three stars). In comparison, the U.S. Army governor-general of occupied Okinawa at the end of World War II was a three-star general. Okinawa is an island in the Ryukyus, 350 miles south of Japan, and is only 80 miles long and 8 to 19 miles wide.

Let's just say, Colonel John Wilder got the shaft when it came to awarding him the appropriate rank he deserved. Perhaps the writer, Ray Bradbury, didn't understand military ranks.

reply

It could also be that he stepped on a few toes along the way while trying to get his Mars program up and running. I mean some of the scenes depict the situation between the different powers on Earth becoming more and more tense and I would imagine many would think in that sort of situation that more defensive systems were what should be worked on, not trips to Mars. So he pushes it through not once, not twice, but three times. The first two times the astronauts vanish without a trace and he keeps on pushing. Plenty of reason for some to have resentments towards Col. Wilder I would think. They can't demote him because he hasn't done anything worthy of a court martial or some such, but they can refuse him promotion. And then when the colony gets started up they'd want to get rid of the thorn in their sides and would ship him off to Mars to head up the colony. After all he's so far off from Earth when on Mars that he can't just make demands of others like he had before.

reply