MovieChat Forums > Superman (1978) Discussion > Why doesn't Superman just close the box ...

Why doesn't Superman just close the box of kryptonite?


When Lex says "dont open it" and he opens it to see its kryptonite, why didn't he just close it and take Lex to prison? Seems daft!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VE4-WkrRs6o

reply

Superman has never encountered Kryptonite before. Probably never felt physical pain before. The shock of experiencing it for the first time in his life had to be an immense sensation. Staggering enough for him to instinctively think of retreating- away from the pain- rather than come closer- increasing the pain- to close the box. By the time he considered doing that, he was too weak to act.

reply

Thanks for that, makes sense now

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VE4-WkrRs6o

reply

But you may ask why Luthor had to make a big song and dance about inviting Superman over and telling him his plan rather than letting the missiles do their work. And why Superman takes his time catching up with the East Coast missile when later we see he can fly so fast he can reverse time...

reply

Lex Luthor wanted everyone - especially Superman - to know that he is the greatest criminal mind of our time. Also, Superman didn't know the extent of his powers until he saw that flying too slow resulted in Lois Lane's death. Then he got serious.

reply

The opposite was also true. Lex didn't know the extent of Superman's powers and couldn't take the chance of leaving him loose. The song and dance was meant to keep him distracted so that he didn't guess his real intentions which was to get him near the Kryptonite.

reply

But you may ask why Luthor had to make a big song and dance about inviting Superman over and telling him his plan rather than letting the missiles do their work.
He wanted to incapacitate Superman, so he needed him to come close to give him the Kryptonite. Superman was his biggest thread and this was the opportunity to catch and kill him. And besides he needed to do this before he sent off the nukes. Had he not, Superman would have likely stopped one or both of them... and even risking him stopping the west coast was not an option. Makes sense.

And why Superman takes his time catching up with the East Coast missile when later we see he can fly so fast he can reverse time...
The death of Lois fueled superman with love and rage and pushed him to a level that even he did not know he could get to. So the short answer is that at the time Superman did not actually know the limit of his powers was that great. But still, he should have been strong enough as his normal self to give the two nukes a run for their money.... so another way to rationalize this is to remember that he lost much valuable time in the pool and also that he was yet weakened by the Kryptonite and so was not at his a-game.

___________
** I am normally not a praying man, but if you are up there, please save me Superman **

reply

Frankly Superman never should have revealed a weakness like being unable to see through lead.


http://www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

maybe another weakness is that he is too honest

reply

I think once it was open, it affected him.

reply

HISHE made fun about his 'time travel reset' ability.. he could've used it to solve all the problems in his life very easily. I wonder, why he didn't.

He could've prevented Luther from ever getting the kryptonite, or building the missiles, etc. He could certainly have fixed everything that's even remotely fixable.

I guess it wouldn't have made a very interesting movie, but my point is, they should never have introduced such an overpowered ability.

reply

Regarding the time travel bit, here's an observation I made while watching last night: Supes is busting his super hump chasing down the two subsonic missiles, barely overtaking one after a lot of effort. He wasn't fast enough to get them both, so one of the missiles hits the San Andreas Fault. Yet, after he discovers Lois starting to cool off, he then circles the entire freaking world [b]5 times a second[b] generating enough air friction to rotate the earth backwards.

Talk about suspending disbelief!

reply

Let's say you are really hungry and there is nothing else in the kitchen and you have a weakness for chocolate brownies.
You open a cupboard door.
And there they are!
One dozen chocolate brownies that your wife made just because she wanted to.
Now are you going to close the door and forget about them or eat a couple because of your weakness?

Damn, I'm good.

reply


"Now are you going to close the door and forget about them or eat a couple because of your weakness?"

This analogy makes no sense whatsoever. A Brownie isn't going to immediately hurt / threaten your life. You can also go buy something more healthy from the store and wean yourself off the temptation.

Brownies don't radiate deadly or power-draining rays, and fridge door isn't going to protect you from these non-existing rays.

Kryptonite isn't food, and weakness for brownies is psychological and indirect, whereas Superman's weakness about Kryptonite is physical/biological and direct.

The threat of brownies is also not immediate, but it's a long-term thing that might never actually harm you in any discernable way, whereas Kryptonite works immediately, hurts him directly and right then and there.

Also, Kryptonite has no temptational property, as it can't offer anything good to Superman, whereas brownie can taste good and fill the stomach, appeasing hunger and thus aiding in suspending a particular kind of pain in a predictable way.

Kryptonite can only cause pain, not alleviate it.

"Damn, I'm good."

If your analogy is any kind of example of your ability, no, you're not.

reply

This point is dead-on right. I am watching the movie right now and this is an entirely stupid part of the scene. Superman still has the strength to stumble around, and he can even tread water with the Kryptonite around his neck. Certainly he had the strength to close the lid to the box. And Superman is generally portrayed as a highly intelligent being; and so it's not credible that he was just in "shock" and could not think "hmmm - opening that box really hurt me -- so maybe I'd better close it back." They could have easily fixed this scene by at least having Superman and Lex struggle with the box lid; in his weakened condition, Superman might not have been able to overcome Luther; that would make sense. But for Superman to just stumble backward and move away from the box was silly.

reply

Because the waves of radiation were absolutely debilitating. He was overwhelmed. I would have thought that obvious from Reeve's performance. The terror on his face, the shock, was utterly convincing. I haven't seen anything as convincing since the night Rachel Maddow realized Trump was going to become POTUS.

reply

...since the night Rachel Maddow realized Trump was going to become POTUS.


I had gone to bed early because I thought the election would never go Trump's way, but I have to admit I did enjoy watching the youtube videos the next day.

reply

Its a plot hole

reply