MovieChat Forums > The Incredible Hulk (1977) Discussion > Should They Have Had More Sci Fi Element...

Should They Have Had More Sci Fi Elements?


Would it have helped if this show incorporated more sci-fi elements, as Stan Lee encouraged them to include? If other 70s sci-fi shows like the 6 MILLION DOLLAR MAN and the BIONIC WOMAN could include plot elements like mad scientists, androids, killer space probes, aliens, insane computers AIs, weather control machines and even Bigfoot, it could have been done in this show as well.

Would the Incredible Hulk have benefited from more sci-fi aspects?

reply

Like George Reeves Superman it's rooted in a kind of cops and robbers format that a lot of shows back then were.

Would've liked Hulk fighting gamma mutants unleashed by gamma rays from sunspots.

reply

Would've helped a bit, all the plots dealt with difficult subjects, crooks, natural disasters etc. It was pretty much the same thing every episode, it's like "what? is that it?".

reply

Even "Adventures of Superman", which was a low budget show, mostly grounded in mundane plots, had the Mole People, a robot and a time machine.

reply

They were afraid of doing that stuff because they didn't want the Hulk to be perceived as a comic book show and feared it would be too silly. Adventures Of Superman was still rooted in a cops and Robbers formula even with mole men and robots.

If a Hulk show was done now it would be super villain of the week like Smallville, Arrow, Flash and Supergirl, and also be in a long arc format.

reply

Androids would have been plausible, but needed to be done seriously, not campy.

Bigfoot was handled indirectly in 'The Antowuk Horror'.

There was a "mad hunter" in 'The Snare'

To include aliens...?

reply

[deleted]

The show managed to do well with its fugitive Jekyll/Hyde premise though it would have been cool to see them embrace a little more from the superhero background. Captain America and Spider-Man suffered a lot more from the bland grounded direction Universal and CBS took them in than the Hulk. Bill Bixby was enough of a charismatic lead that it wasn't torture waiting to see Ferrigno rip a few shirts and show some feats of strength.

It really would have been cool (to me) to see Ross or Talbot hunting the Hulk, or maybe even see Betty tying to help him. Hmm, I guess these are things they did in the 90s cartoon but I think they'd have worked.

reply

Not quite sure why they outten Ross, Betty and Talbot, the only character used was the central character.

Love the 90's cartoon.

reply

I think had the show benefited with more Sci-fi elements, e.g mad scientists, androids etc, it might have reduced the episode numbers. The show even though with it's budget, did use a lot of stock footage, for cost purposes... It probably worked out easier and cheaper to work more grounded in reality then science fiction...

reply

But would they get away with more sci fi elements nowadays?

reply

Oh, I don't know...


I am sure that some fans would have liked to have had a more Sci-Fi/Comic book tone to the show... And even I would have liked to have seen a few stories done in this area...

But, Honestly, I think one of the things that made this show so good, and still holds up today, was that fact that it didn't...

Also, as noted by other posters in this thread, is the fact the show didn't have a huge budget. As I recall, people who worked on the show and who have been interviewed have said, they could only have David "Hulk Out" twice per episode. Even in episodes like "The First"... it seems pretty cheap by show standards today. Seriously, two hulks fighting, and they barely touched one another? And the only thing that was damaged was a room? Episodes like that, wouldn't happen today!

...Most episodes dealt with aspects of the human condition... And my favorites were the one which David had to deal with himself.


Like the episode "Homecoming", where David returns home, because he didn't want to be alone on Thanksgiving... and he has to deal with his estranged relationship with his father...

or at the end of "The First, Part 2", When Del Frye's creature breaks the syringe containing the last of the cure, and David breaks down crying because his salvation has been taken away from him...

or "The Psychic", When David thinks the Hulk killed someone and David has an emotional breakdown and considers suicide.

And I still love "The Pilot" episode where David is frustrated while trying to find out why he couldn't save his wife, while others could...



Most of what I remember from the show, isn't about The Hulk... It was about David Banner! And that is because you could identify with David every time. The Hulk was just there to save David's life or solve the villain of the week problem.

That probably all had to do with the show having such a small budget... The writers had to create good stories to tell, instead of relying on a bunch of gimmicks to keep audiences interested.

Now, don't get me wrong, not every story was great, and there were a few stinkers that were hard to forget...



Thank Goodness, the show had two great actors like Bill Bixby & Jack Colvin to help tell all those great stories...

And not every scene was taken seriously either, which added some levity to the show, and made it more interesting. The Banner avoiding McGee scenes were always fun to watch.


It was a great show in its day, and still holds up today, but, I don't think it would be made the same way today, with modern day audiences.

A new show would have to have a more Sci-Fi/Comic book tone... Sadly...

reply