MovieChat Forums > The Goodbye Girl (1977) Discussion > Should have been called 'The Shack Up Gi...

Should have been called 'The Shack Up Girl'


I remember seeing this movie as a kid, and just being thrilled that Paula found love again with Elliott. Then I got older. Now when I see it, I just want to scream, "Run Elliott! Run! You didn't give her your PIN code did you?" What was it, their 2nd night in bed together, she's already planning to buy a new living room set? Then after he pays for all the new furniture, she asks him how long until he can afford to buy her the arm chair? And that terrific line she shouts out the window, "I'm going to be right here, spending your money on OUR apartment!"
And lets not forget that she and her daughter moved in with Tony after 1 week. Uno. At the beginning of the movie, she comes into the apartment with all the bags of clothes and calls through the bathroom door, "We bought out Alexanders!" Well, since she hadn't worked in 2 years, would this be with her married lover's money, I assume?
Great mom.



"Would you like to see a long arm, Otis?"

reply

Yep, women really drain money from men.

reply

I already have a thread going on this subject:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0076095/board/thread/67607932

It's unfortunate, too, because I like GG. I just think Elliott needs to think long and hard about what he's getting himself into.





http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2BU8-7kQLI

reply

Paula will not be ignored!

reply

[deleted]

Thank you! Thankyouverymuch.

reply



Hmmmmmmm............Ladies and gentlemen, if I'm not completely mistaken, ELVIS hassssss left the building !!!!!!!


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elvis_has_left_the_building

reply

Woah! And I always thought that was about the king of rock 'n' roll, Mr. Costello!

reply


WAIT A MINUTE !!!!!! You mean to tell me that Bud Abbott's partner had a career in music, too ?????


SAVE FERRIS

reply

I disliked her from the minute she allowed Lucy to read Tony's note... She's in hysterics when her daughter needs somebody strong to look up to as a protector. Quit whining and start worrying about how you're gonna look after your child already, instead of only thinking about yourself!






Born when she kissed me, died when she left me, lived whilst she loved me

reply

You are judging a 1977 Paula by 2008 standards. In 1977 women were by and large housewives. The man made the money and the woman spent it on the household. The idea of a woman carrying her own financial weight was new and much scorned at that time. Even with couples who hadn't yet had children it wasn't unusual for the woman to be a homemaker, not work outside the home.

reply

Yep, back in the 1970's women were way more likely to be housewives. And I took the spending money on new furnature and redecorating as the two starting a new life together. They were no longer living alone along with the other people in the apartment, they were now living together.

reply

Thank you so much!

I loved how Paula would nickel-and-dime Elliot's food usage, mock his healthy habits, and various "eccentricities," yet once she can see him as a potential gravy train, she's all over him.

Besides? Who knows just how many guitars Elliot has left behind in his life (in order to get away from just this thing)? (haha)

Great post.

reply

I could understand Paula sponging off, I mean, building a life with Elliot. In the mid to late 70s, that was the life goal/identity for the majority of women. Women who didn't follow that path were still kind of seen as renegades, outside of the norm.

The part that got on my nerves was when Paula stood out in the pouring rain with Elliot's guitar. Really? She knows how important the instrument is to the guy, yet she's ruining it on purpose? It's not like she has the money to replace the warped wooden guitar when it doesn't dry out correctly.




No two persons ever watch the same movie.

reply