MovieChat Forums > Robin and Marian (1976) Discussion > If not for the bloody apples. . .

If not for the bloody apples. . .


. . . greatness!
Anachronisms: Golden Delicious apples (in windows during last scene) did not exist in 13th century England.

Thanks, "Professor Appleseed!" JK

reply

Thats reminds me of the bit in BEN HUR where that cow in the barn with Mar and Joe
did yet exist



http://www.moola.com:80/moopubs/b2b/exc/join.jsp?sid=4d6a55744d7a45794e544d3d-2

reply

I actually liked the apples.

reply

"Golden" or yellow apples have been around in one form or another for centuries. In mythology and folklore "golden" apples appear with some frequency, bearing a variety of meanings. In such stories it is sometimes unclear whether the apples are actually "golden," or simply yellow apples called as such. Whether or not the apples in the scene were golden delicious or not, it is not really an anachronism, but more likely either an intentional visual nod to a common folkloric element, or simply a good excuse for a splash of color in an otherwise dour scene (possibly hinting at a bright afterlife to come). Furthermore, when it comes to adding yet another (rather ingenious) twist to the timeless Robin Hood legend, such an "anachronism" is easily forgiven.

grumpyoldguy

reply

Couldn't they spring for a decent horticultural historian? Those Golden Delicious apples ruined the whole movie for me...NOT!

reply

Couldn't they spring for a deceny horticultural historian? Those Golden Delicious apples ruined the whole movie for me...NOT!

reply

Bro... you double posted.

reply

Well, at least they weren't kiwis. How embarrassing would that have been?

reply

Good point. The produce we eat today is much different than it was centuries ago.

reply