MovieChat Forums > Tommy (1975) Discussion > the worse part about this movie ....

the worse part about this movie ....


that young kids dont appreciate the art that Tommy has used. Tommy is such a beautiful movie, music is awesome, its really not that trippy if you understand the metaphores. There are teeney boppers out there today who only listen to emo are whatever crud is out there today and the only poems they like to read are about death or why the girlfriends or boyfriends broke up with them. You can't change to what they listen to today but when they come onto this website and bash the crap out of this movie becuase it wasn't like Pink Floyd the Wall, its just bothersome. But any who im not comparing this to The Wall. Both Rock operas at there best, both well directed.

From the people who brought you BIG MOMMAS HOUSE and THE MATRIX comes. BIG MOMMAS MATRIX HOUSE

reply

I know exactly what you mean, I tried to show it to some of my friends who are just like the kids you described. Didn't go well :(

reply

Right there with that guy who posted before me. I am 15 a personally love the film it's great but so many people are just like it's crap. Than they pretend that they listen to the Who because they find their parents old shirts. I liked this movie, I like the Wall, and I went out to this store near me and got all the Who albems they had. I totally understand what this guy is saying about my generation but at least some of us have taste.

Oz-HaHa I've been shot it's really werid... And painful.

reply

i think the generation of wiloz and me are stuck to that "i dont wanna think" mentality, if the ending isnt presented or the reason isnt presented directly, they dont bother to think about it, back when i first saw this movie, i saw alot of it kind of in a shocking light... and that machine the queen had creeped the bloody hell out of me, but the point im making is, im 20, saw it 9 years ago, and then saw it agian around 16, and then again a month ago... this movie always seemed to have me thinking the people were pretty damn foolish, and if you think about it, thats what alot of the subplot is layed around, you see tommy's parents going nuts not willing to accept their actions, the entire movement to follow tommy was just to show how low humans really are in regards to our beliefs. Take a look at the modern music scene for example, girls will iconolize artists, essentially diefying them, one girl i knew had an obsession with simple plan, and one day i blurted out; " you DO realize they are just human beings, they eat mcdonalds, they *beep* in a toilet, they get sick and puke in a bucket next to their bed, and its damn possible they arent happy with themselves at times" and her retort... "bull! their so cute and everything about them is so perfect", even with the scene where tommy's real dad comes back and the new guy kills him, it was just like a wild animal taking out a rival, tommy becomes the weak one, where his cousin and uncle prey upon him without remorse, I loved this movie... granted, i didnt understand it very well at 11, but at 16 i got the basics of it, and now alot of it is pretty understandable, and im still kinda disheartened that there was plans for a follow up to tommy that got scrapped... baba o'riely is a leftover of one of the songs meant for it, and yeah the bean scene was odd, but it was one of the most simple things to understand for me, the commercial of something that looks so unattractive as beans set in such an extravagant setting, i think she started to freak out and think of herself as something that shouldnt of been where it was... oh hell what do i know, i even like Phantom of the Paradise

reply

i only just saw this film tonite, and i'm...stunned. it blew me way. i'm 14 and i got it, not bragging but you have to have a certain...openness to watch it and get the meaning.

and the acid queen's machine creeped me out.
and i'm .supposed. to be desensited and stupid.

i hate having people judge me because of my age.

reply

[deleted]

Hey! Don't be trying to put us d-d-down.

But seriously, this generation is pretty lame. They write off anything that they can't instantly understand. Hence why lyrical quality has gone down hill like mad over the last few years.

reply

Ahahaha! So true.


I'm 16 and my Dad showed me Tommy just last night, I expected it to be really boring, I hadn't heard much about it, so I expected it to be a lame comedy/musical or something but once I started watching it I loved it, one of the best movies I've seen.
Loved the music, the acting everything.

I asked a couple of my friends if they'd seen it before and they were all like, yeah it's crap, really trippy.

I expect if I show it to my friends they'll be like WTF is this crap!? and make fun of me for liking it, they're all into that emo/depressing stuff. something I'll never understand.

reply

"the commercial of something that looks so unattractive as beans set in such an extravagant setting, i think she started to freak out and think of herself as something that shouldnt of been where it was."

I love this explination of your interpretation.

xxx

reply

Another part i left out is that she made herself ugly because she exploited her son for that life, so the life she always wanted was spoiled imperfectly because her presence destroyed... then again i could also over analyze it but meh... i like my over analyzations

I R Teh Banana

reply

You sound a lot like me Andawn. The Who is probably my favorite band. A lot of my friends wear who/floyd shirts as well but they've only heard the really popular albums. I've got a lot of pf and everything of The Who's for studio aside from It's Hard and Endless Wire which I haven't picked up yet. I pretty much only started listening to music this may, but I just sampled all the genres I could and I found out Progressive Rock, Classic Rock, and Psychedelic are my favorites. I agree with the op btw. This movie is definitely art and under appreciated at that.

reply

I'm 15, and 99.9% of my friends hate anything intelligent.
They'd rather listen to Panic at the *beep* than David Bowie, just because "he's weird."
If I showed them this movie, they'd wet themselves in fear.

"I'm superstitious. Whenever I start a new movie I kill a hobo with a hammer."-Gwyneth Paltrow

reply

[deleted]

My friend told me "I only hated this movie because you would only skip to the worse scenes! If I knew there was good parts of the movie too, I wouldn't hate it so much" when she finally watched the whole thing with me.

. .. ... .... .....

reply

poor you !

I'm 16, and one day I tried to explain to my best friend that Pink Floyd and The Who are in another (better) class of music than Green Day, he was like : "I don't like Pink Floyd songs because they don't have a melody", I mean what have you got to say to that ! And then I explain that Pink Floyd and The Who don't just fling a simplistic chord progression and repeat throughout a WHOLE ALBUM, but that their albums have a concept, even a story (the Wall, Tommy), and they actually pay attention to what they say in their lyrics, that talk about something else than girlfriends and boyfriends, and he's like : "But whats the point in good lyrics, whats the point in there having a story ?"
What do you say to that ?

PS : I know American Idiot is supposed to be a rock opera, but its basically a joke.

reply

You say "screw you" and walk away.

The words "clean" and "wholesome" make me want to run in the oppisite direction.

reply

i'm 15 and i absolutley LOVE this movie!! and i have friends that do, but i have friends that don't its just a matter of opinion.

reply

im 12 and i saw this movie when i was 10 AND IVE LOVED IT EVER SINCE ITS SO Amazing and i love the wall too i have both :) i was brouht up with good music and thats what i like

RIP Chris Farley,River Phoenix,Heather O Rourke,Phil Hartman,Kurt Cobain

reply

I'm not even born yet - still a fetus in my mother's womb - but TOMMY is my favorite movie forever! My mother fell asleep in front of our hi-def TY and I absorbed all the images through her belly skin. Weird, I know. But not only did I - a fetus, mind you - enjoy TOMMY, I absolutely understood it! That's not entirely true... mommy was listening to her Who on the BBC CDs and I heard Pete Townsend saying that TOMMY is about... wait a minute, mommy's got to pee and I have to shut down my Mac so my typing doesn't annoy her on the toilet.

I have one more thing to say: even though I loved the images in the film, I think the music is mostly crap. Mommy played the 5.0 mix, from the original "quintophonic" soundtrack, and there are superflous synthesizer flourishes ALL OVER THE MUSIC! It's very annoying, even to me, a fetus. Someday, after I'm born, I want to mate the original album, you know, by THE WHO, to the film. I'm already learnkng iMovie so I can - hopefully - have it done by the time I'm 6 or 7 months old.

OOPS! Here goes mommy.... WEEEEEEE!!!!

reply

I am in middle school, and on my iPod, the "Top 25 Most Played" playlist is filled with songs from "The Wall" and lots of Who songs. Though I think "Quadrophenia" is the best album ever (The Who is my favorite band), Tommy is still awesome. There are only a few other kids in my school who listen to this sweet music (they all listen to (c)rap), and I am disapointed that they have given their attention to rappers who think they know music.

P.S. I am a Green Day fan, too. Sure, they're not as good, but The Who is one of their biggest influences. They even have a cover of "My Generation" on "Kerplunk!".

http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=15136537

reply

[deleted]

yea my mom makes fun of me for watching it. she's into that gay hip hop as my friends are. i can't watch this movie with any peace. =(

Lady:"who is Stuntman Mike?" Warren:"he's a stuntman."

reply

[deleted]

That's pretty ironic, having parents into the stupid current fads when you're the one liking retro stuff....
I thought that's how my parents were, but they like a lot of stuff like this too.

. .. ... .... .....

reply

optical_ayeaye, that's pretty stupid thing to say, calling rap a stupid fad. It's an established genre that's been in the mainstream for over 20 years now. When rock emerged, people like you were calling it a stupid fad, well it's pretty evident now, it's wasn't.

BTW this is coming from a fan of rock, and more specifically, The Who.
There is rap that transcends the stupidity of alot of it. If you want an example it suggest you go and listen to, Lupe Fiasco's The Cool is a concept album similar to The Wall, and Tommy, in that it's based around a central character, and deals with many issues, through symbolism.
I definitely like rock more than rap, but I have an appreciation for all music that is good, my ears aren't limited by social reservations placed on certain genres.

Not every band in the 60's and 70's were doing what Pink Floyd and The Who, and Zeppelin, and the Beatles, and all those legends were doing.

---------------->
Insert witty, amusing and pithy diatribe here.

...Formerly KnifeySpooney...

reply

I'm not even born yet - still a fetus in my mother's womb - but TOMMY is my favorite movie forever! My mother fell asleep in front of our hi-def TY and I absorbed all the images through her belly skin. Weird, I know. But not only did I - a fetus, mind you - enjoy TOMMY, I absolutely understood it! That's not entirely true... mommy was listening to her Who on the BBC CDs and I heard Pete Townsend saying that TOMMY is about... wait a minute, mommy's got to pee and I have to shut down my Mac so my typing doesn't annoy her on the toilet.

I have one more thing to say: even though I loved the images in the film, I think the music is mostly crap. Mommy played the 5.0 mix, from the original "quintophonic" soundtrack, and there are superflous synthesizer flourishes ALL OVER THE MUSIC! It's very annoying, even to me, a fetus. Someday, after I'm born, I want to mate the original album, you know, by THE WHO, to the film. I'm already learnkng iMovie so I can - hopefully - have it done by the time I'm 6 or 7 months old.
LOL....what.....the...*bleep*?!?!? ROFL ~ best post here!! Seriously!

¸«¤º°»«ëÕ|{¥(V)°º¤»¸
I can't understand your crazy moon language.

reply

You know what though, everyone I actually manage to get to watch Tommy more than once get into so much they end up buying the CD, DVD and repeat view regularly like myself.

It is just an awesome piece of work which should be appreciated more.

Better to regret something you did, than something you didn't do!

reply

I got one of my female cousins in to Tommy. She knew for a long time I was a Who fan and told me one day on a plane flight one of the inflight radio sations had the broadway soundtrack in full playing and she listened and loved it. She asked me to make her a mix tape of Tommy using the album running order using versions of each song in my favorite version or what I thought was the best one.

She loved it alot, I caught up with her a while later and she said she played the tape daily for a year, saw the movie version on tv and loved it and also bought the cd of the Who's Meaty Beaty Big and Bouncy best of.

reply

I'm 14 and I love this movie!! And I don't listen to emo, well, I'm different from the other people of my age.

Pull the string, pull the string!

reply

15 and this movie is the greatest.

reply

I'm 15. I just watched Tommy and I love it. The music is just awsome. The plot is a little thin. But I still loved it!
As for the guy who said that My Generation thinks Pink Floyd the Wall is better than this is wrong. That, my friend, would be bulls*t. Most people my age I know haven't even heard of The Wall. And the only reason they know about Tommy is because this kid's Dad has a Tommy "themed" pinball machine.

Dear sexy knickers I don't half fancy you meet me outside at 5:30 and we'll get it together

reply

I know exactly what you mean. I'm sixteen now but I've been interested in The Who since I was fourteen. Finally got around to watching this, and loved it. I think people try to watch the movie thinking it's going to be a 'musical' like Wicked, or the Hairspray movie or something along those lines. And when they say it's crap, to them it's crap because they can only see it that way. I'm personally ashamed of my generation (no pun intended), and wish they could see this film for the beautiful work of art that it is. Another thing that someone mentioned earlier was that kids try to pretend they listen to The Who because they found their parent's old shirts. I actually confronted one of these so-called Who fans at my school wearing my self-bought tie-dye Tommy shirt and I asked him what its significance was. He told me it was a stupid shirt that I probably won from a pinball game (It says "Tommmy sure plays a mean pinball") and that it didn't mean anything.

I rofled and called him a poser. :)

On a side note: If anyone wants to check out the video on Psychedelic/Acid rock from the sixties for school, you can find it at the following link. It has a whole Tommy section: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWDQF4cDEtM

---
T~O
"Hell's Not So Bad If You Get To Keep An Angel With You"

reply

The only thing that disturbs me that it appears that real actual disabled (most notably blind and cerebral palsy) patients were used.

I'm sure they were compensated in some way, but it still seems exploitation to me.

By the way, I LOVED the typing pool! If they still had that, maybe I'd be working again.

reply

My friends just don't like anything older than them.
It was like when we watched 'Psycho' for our English coursework, they automatically hated it because it was older than them.
It's ridiculous how closed-minded most young people are nowadays. Then I get tarred with the same bloody brush.

I am living proof that coffee stunts your growth.

reply