Anyone Ever Read the Book?


The movie just came on TV and I couldn't figure out why the title seemed so familiar.....

I just realized I read the book many years ago.

reply

I'm actually reading the book right now.
I'm not so interested in the climbing parts of the book, but I'm pushing through because I want to finish it. It helps that I've seen the movie a few times, so I'm pretty familiar with the characters. It's helping to get me through.
I loved Clint Eastwood as Hemlock, and I love it even more as I read the book. Not only was he a great fit for the role, but he has great onscreen chemistry with the actors portraying Big Ben and Jemima.
Have you read anything else by Trevanian?

reply

yes, book was great (clint f'd up the movie big time) as are most works by Trevanian. Highly recommend Shibumi!

reply

hey, pbll - 'Who must do the difficult things?' 'Those who can'. Shibumi.

:-) canuckteach (--:

reply

[deleted]

yes, book was great (clint f'd up the movie big time) as are most works by Trevanian. Highly recommend Shibumi!


I don't agree that Clint "f'd up the movie" at all. From what I remember, the book was better. But then again, isn't that usually the case? The movie wasn't Eastwood's greatest but I didn't find it to be bad at all.

reply

Most folks--not all--but most who visit the message boards at IMDB don't know how to read.
Okay, cheap shot. The book was dull and the movie was ridiculous.

reply

[deleted]

Yep, great book. Lousy movie, although the climbing stuff was cool. Movie didnt carry any of the complexitys of the Hemlock character....most of Trevanians books are good value, but probably wouldnt translate well to screen cause most of them dont have happy endings...Look at the Loo Sanction.

reply

Fantastic book (as is Loo Sanction & the rest of Trevanian's books). You are absolutely right, cool climbing scenes, but the movie missed the complexity of Hemlock, and most of the other characters as well. Trevanian called it a "vapid film." I think he was being generous.

It is probably a much better movie to someone who hasn't read the book.

reply

About 30 years ago I was in DC's Moonstone Bookstore(sci-fi, mystery) one Sunday when a couple came in looking for some books to take on vacaction. Phil Grosfeld, the owner, recommended Trevanian, and they said they were friends of his.
According to them Trevanian was Jack Hashem(?) who administered the CETA program and lived in Vienna, Va. Of course, this was at odds with a scant info the publishers provided. The POST'S government column Mike Causey interviewed Hashem who said he wrote books under a pseudonym. I called Causey who was quite surprised and said he liked the books.

Hashem wrote one book under his own name, but I don't remember the title, and he wrote a King Arthur novel(with locker room humor) under another name. Of course, this is all years and years ago, and my memory falters at times.

Very interesting to find somebody else identified as Trevanian.

reply

I read it years ago and remember enjoying it. If I remember right, the character of Hemlock was a lot more amoral. I never read the Loo Sanction however, could the previous poster tell me how it ends that is so downbeat?

reply

Way too many years since I read the books. Ross Thomas, another Washington novelist used to live down the street from me, but I don't know if I ever would've known him if we passed on the street.

Charles Bronson starred in St. Ives, which was based on one of Thomas' books, and I thought Bronson was miscast. Bronson told Thomas "I didn't read the book" to which Thomas replied "That's okay. I didn't see your last movie." I think Thomas also wrote the "Hammett" script.

reply

I have read the book innumerable times, and enjoy all of Trevanian's stuff. His black humour, and sending up of architypes, is fantastic.

reply

[deleted]

Back about 1980 a school friend recommended the book,I said I saw the film and it was not good,he agreed and said read the book,later I read the book and he was right.Is it still in print?

Look what your brother did to the door!

reply

[deleted]

My understanding is Whitaker and Gresham(?) wrote the books based on Whitaker's obituary in the Post some years ago. Gresham did publish a WWI novel whose title I don't recall. The information I imparted was based on a conversation one Sunday afternoon with two friends of his at the old Moonstone bookstore in DC. I rarely claim to be totally accurate except on things I have personal knowledge about such as knowing Larry McMurtry before he wrote Lonesome Dove or the night Jimmy Dean came over to my greatgrandmother's house to watch Andy Griffith in a live version of No Time for Sergeants. But those are stories for another day.

Thanks for writing.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Sorry, but I was having a senior moment when I said Gresham(?) had written the books. This was a posting from six years ago, and the name was Jack Hasham who was in charge of the CETA program at the time the books were being written.

There was even speculation that Robert Ludlum was Trevanian because of the similiarity of his book Trevayne and Trevanian. I also have a story about Ludlum.

reply

[deleted]

Yes.

I read the Eiger Sanction and liked it. When the Loo Sanction came out I bought it and it was OK but I thought the Eiger Sanction was better.

Bought Shubumi in an airport book store on vacation and read it on my trip. Liked it even less.

Then I read The Summer of Katya. Very disappointed. Didn't care for it at all.

Stopped reading Trevanian after that.

reply

[deleted]

My wife got it for me when I was in hospital in 1975. Read it in a couple of hours, did not think much of it.

When the film came out I wondered how Clint Eastwood was going to play a man described as 5'9" tall.

reply

The book never fully described Hemlock's height so youre lying, it only said he was of medium height and that was it.

----------------------------------------
DIE, FANBOY, DIE 

reply