MovieChat Forums > Chinatown (1974) Discussion > Goldsmith's score one of the 2 greatest...

Goldsmith's score one of the 2 greatest ever


Does any score convey mood more effectively and economically than Chinatown's?

Its brilliance is particularly ironic given how abominable its predecessor was (Thank God Polanski et al demanded a new score!) and how little time Goldsmith had to compose it. 10 days! Miraculous.

The only score I can think of on that level is Lawrence of Arabia's - and God knows how long it Jarre to write it!

That said, I also adore Elmer Bernstein's waltz in the opening of To Kill a Mockingbird.

reply

The producer Robert Evans and the composer Bronislau Kaper lead the effort to get the previous and terrible score changed despite Polanski's reservations that there wasn't enough time. (Confirmed by the Chinatown Blu-ray featurettes) So Polanski had little to nothing to do with Goldsmith's score.

But yes, Chinatown is the most ingeniously spotted score in cinema and it happens to be both elegant and alien/unease. The scene where Jake Gittes surveys Ida Sessions' apartment is literally scored like a sci-fi/horror film and is apposite and superb.

The avant-garde piano and string effects juxtaposed with a jazzy/bluesy trumpet melody in a 23 minute score (17.6% of the film scored) gives the film a distinctive atmosphere, makes it one of Goldsmith's most innovative scores as well as one of the most versatile scores in general.

A demonstration of how matchless this score is in its spotting and as brilliant as anything in the much-lauded Towne screenplay or Polanski direction is Goldsmith's first reprise of the trumpet theme.

After the opening credits, the famous trumpet theme is held back a staggering 83 minutes and only first reappearing after Jake Gittes is saved by Evelyn Mulwray for a second time, indicating that he's enamored with the woman who has now twice rescued him. That is as ingenious timing as you'll ever perceive in a film.

The fact that every single cue is specific to the dramatic elements in a sparse 23 minute score, composed in 10 days nonetheless, means that no score is more brilliantly economical or brilliant. (It also runs circles around classic film noir scores)

reply

As a Jazz fan I agree the score is great, a new favorite. Loved it as soon as i heard it. But to me, from what I've heard/seen, Once Upon a Time In America is my favorite movie score. If you haven't seen it, make the time.

reply

To be sure, Chinatown is not actually a jazz score, as probably over 70% of the score are avant-garde effects.

Here's noted music critic Alex Ross on what makes the Chinatown score great:

The stroke of genius was in juxtaposing the unforgettably moody title theme with various avant-garde devices, notably a lot of strumming and plucking on the strings of four grand pianos. Adventurous as it is, the music is perfectly in keeping with the movie's period setting, Henry Cowell having pioneered inside-the-piano techniques in Northern California in the second decade of the century.

http://www.therestisnoise.com/2004/07/more_sadness.html

Goldsmith's brilliance makes this score original and innovative, as well has hauntingly beautiful.

reply