is this true?


Somebody was telling me recently that the only reason this movie was made was because Warner Brothers were set to sue Elliott Gould after his drug use and erratic behaviour made them pull the plug on a comedy he was making.
Even though he was estranged from Babs at the time, La Streisand stepped in and said she'd take his place if Warner stopped their court action. She was seeing Ryan O'Neal at the time and she made his casting in the movie a condition of the deal.
It might explain why she never expected the film to be a hit.
Has anybody else ever heard this story?

reply

[deleted]

Yes, the above is true. WHAT'S UP, DOC began life as a black comedy called GLIMPSE OF THE TIGER, which was to star Gould as a criminal who forces himself into a young woman's life and corrupts her. When Gould's drug/gambling habits prevented him from being able to shoot the picture, Barbra step in to help, and the studio decided it was best from her to play the Gould character, and to recast the female part as a male (which became the part played by O'Neal).

Peter Bogdanovich was Streisand's first choice to direct because she loved THE LAST PICTURE SHOW. However, Bogdanovich didn't like the original screenplay's dark tone and whated to make it a light, screwball comedy. I'm glad he did - as DOC is my favorite comedy. Anyway, definitely a intersting backstory, you can read about it in more detail in James Spada's excellent book on Streisand, or many of the other Streisand bios.

reply

I have also read that Streisand believed throughout the filming of the the movie that it was going to be a stinker. She kept telling O'Neal "I don't think this is going to be any good."

reply

[deleted]

Hard to imagine it as a dark comedy, the way it turned out! Strange how things go.

reply

So, as far as we can ascertain, it is true. Fantastic. Yeah, it is pretty hard to imagine it as a dark comedy. Suppose it's what people call serendipity...

reply

If you want to see what could have been, the original screenplay was based on a novel, "A Glimpse of Tiger," by Herman Raucher (fresh of his success with 1971's "Summer of '42"). He also wrote the aborted screenplay, and the first draft of "What's Up Doc," though Buck Henry's alterations were such that Raucher never received credit and was essentially screwed out of getting any money; they changed everything "just a little bit," time and time again, to the point that they ended up completely changing everything save for the most basic of premises.

The original movie would have told the story of Luther (to be played by Gould), a 30 year old New York con-artist who takes in a runaway 19 year old girl from Kentucky, whom he nicknames Tiger. Together, the two survive in the city by living off of stipends from Luther's wealthy, careless parents, and by pulling cons such as convincing subway passengers that Luther's a blind folk musician who needs their patronage to survive, and eating their meals by invading the free sample booths at department stores. Luther lives life through games, though; he never acts serious, is always childish, and when pressed to express true emotion, assumes the identities of made up characters and acts screwy until the situation has blown over. When he impulsively takes in a pair of drifters, one of whom ODs on LSD, Tiger moves out and sets about trying to make her own way in life. Wacky hijinks ensue as Luther tries to win her back through a variety of hairbraned schemes.

SPOILERS---





In the final chapter, Luther finally acknowledges that Tiger no longer has any need for him and that he isn't a part of her life anymore. They part as friends, and she goes to work the next day looking ahead to the great things that await her. Luther--whom we now see is not some crazy, loveable screwball, but an obsessed loon-- then calls in to the building to inform them that he's planted a bomb there, and summarily blows the office up, killing Tiger.

reply

Wow. Must get my hands on it. Sounds extremely interesting. Hard to imagine it being made, though, isn't it? Especially today...

reply

That sounds like a fascinating idea for a film.

"Welcome to the SH, Bitch."
- Gilmore Girls

reply

Yes, this story is pretty much accurate. I read about it in James Spada's biography on Streisand.

reply

What's Up, Doc is one of my favorite movies, too, and the above version sounds nothing like it. It does sound good, though. I'd like to see it made. Why not as a modern movie?

Or even as a TV movie. A lot of interest could be generated just from the background history; the story would pick up where ever it was distributed or sold and therefore get automatic press for the movie.

YA! --------------------- YA!

BREAKING NEWS VALENTINE SPECIAL! announces a romantic balled to the tune of John Denver's, "Take Me Home, Country Road," called "Katie Holmes (Take Tom Home)," is now available to all maniacs. So dust down your guitar, and get learning!

http://www.thebreakingnews.piczo.com/
(Truth Not Provided.)
Also! 'The Paris Hilton Doesn't Know Where She Is Scandal!' 'The Scarlett Johansson Monogamy/Mahogany Sizzing Sex Shocker!' + Review of New Movie 'MANIA: The Lion, The Gorilla, & The Twelve Year Old Magician!'

"I never forget a face, but in your case I'll make an exception." Groucho.

reply