MovieChat Forums > The King of Marvin Gardens (1972) Discussion > Boy Howdy -- talk about a 'grower'

Boy Howdy -- talk about a 'grower'


I've seen this movie only four times in the last fifteen years.

The first time I was a fifteen year old riding high on watching Five Easy Pieces over and over, loving that I was finally seeing what seemed to be a genuine human being I could relate to in a movie. When I heard Jack and Bob R. collaborated on another film, I dashed out to find it. Aside from the opening scene, I found The King of Marvin Gardens to be an utter disappointment.

I gave it another shot roughly five years later. I can't remember the circumstances, but I do remember thinking, "That wasn't so bad."

Then, another five years later, I bought a used copy of the DVD. Still better.

Now, having seen it a fourth time last weekend, I feel like I could sit down and enjoy it at any time. It's so richly observed, and there doesn't seem to be a single false note anywhere in the entire bloody movie. Think about that! How many films -- character-driven dramas, no less -- can claim to be 100% savvy when it comes to representing the human condition?

I guess that's another way of saying, "I've met all these people, and I bet you have too."

Beautifully shot, as well. I don't think there's any score, which was a wise decision, if for no other reason because it adds to quiet devastation of the film's final moments.

Anyway, I'm not sure what purpose this post serves, but I felt compelled to add something to this message board.

reply

Some Casino should show this with "Atlantic City" at midnight every Friday and Saturday nights.

Poets are made by fools like me, but only God can make STD.

reply

I arrived on the same ship. It's got to do with the magnitude of Five Easy Pieces, because that's what brought us here. Surely one of the most overlooked American films in history as it's Rafelson's greatest film along with Pieces. So tough to compare the two because they are just that damn different in the end.

And you know that's why no one knows about this one - I'm sure lots of people rushed to see it back in the day and probably people still do, but they don't care to give it a second viewing and most of us are expecting somekind of Five Easy Pieces: Part II, which this is absolutely not.

reply

This is a very interesting thread.Its certainly got me thinking about TKoMG again. Its true that I rushed to see this film off the back of being knocked out by Five Easy Pieces. Its also true that I was hoping to see a sort of Five part II. So I was pretty disappointed and wrote TKoMG off as boring. Now 10+ years later I can see that its just a totally different film. So thanks folks for pointing me back to the King of Marvin Gardens I am going to try again.

reply

It's definitely a film that needs to be seen a couple of times before it's power is realised.




"I'm not Spartacus."

reply