MovieChat Forums > M*A*S*H (1972) Discussion > Biggest Continuity Goof

Biggest Continuity Goof


I know it's been discussed a lot but having seen it just now, a huge error was the 'A War For All Seasons' episode which starts with a New Year's Eve party at the end of 1950. As IMDB explains,

'The opening and ending scenes have Colonel Potter leading the 4077th in celebrating the end of the year 1950 and 1951 respectfully. In his initial appearance in Season 4's "Change of Command", Potter replaces Colonel Henry Blake as Commanding Officer, and it is announced that the date of his arrival was September 17, 1952. Therefore Colonel Potter would not have been at the 4077th on New Year's Eve 1950 nor 1951. Neither Maj. Winchester nor BJ Hunnicut should have been there either, given the time they arrived in relation to Col. Potter. This also means Radar, Captain McIntyre, and Maj. Burns should have been present as well.'

Plus, the Korean War started June 25, 1950. That means a lot of MASH events would have been compressed into 6 months. Like, say, Trapper and Hawkeye going behind enemy lines to pick up wounded American prisoners held by the Chinese, who weren't even in the war until November 1950.

reply

This has been beaten to death. I have no problem with the change.

Potter had arrived on 11/17/52, about 10 months before the end of the Korean War. I highly doubt anyone in their wildest dreams thought that the show would last as long a it did. I suspect that they thought that the show might last till season 7, but it just kept going and stayed popular, especially for a show going into it's 9 season, with a 10th season in the works. Henry had been there for 3 seasons for over 2 years of war. Not a good balance.

Potter was going into his 6th season, twice as long as Henry(episode wise), and had a long time to go ratings wise. It was getting more than a bit unrealistic that the final 10 months of the war would last for 6+ seasons.


Destroying an empire to win a war is no victory and ending a battle to save an empire is no defeat

reply

Your just going to have to learn to suspend disbelief and separate the real time line of the war from a fictitious TV show.

Was there really a Korean War of which the American forces took part in an invasion of Korea?
Yes.
Is there a book, movie and TV show based on this invasion of American forces which is focused on an Army hospital near enemy lines?
Yes.
Did everything that happens in the TV show actually really happen at an Army hospital in Korea during the war?
Except for wounded coming in, really, really very, very doubtful.
So the producers, directors, script writers and actors are taking liberties, even the timeline, for the TV show compared to the actual invasion and war by American forces in Korea?
Yes.

reply

That was General Steele. Not Col. Potter. There that settles it.

reply

I think it was twice we were told that CHINA joined the North in the war.
Also twice that MacArthur went home and was replaced.

on location with SUPERMAN I,& OTHER STARS
http://www.vbphoto.biz/

reply

I know what you are saying and there are heaps of inaccuracies in the show.

The thing is what if they go by actual timeline and found that the war ended before the show was due or the show ended up getting axed before they had time to "end the war" in the show.

Just one of those things, the Vietnam war would have been better as it went longer but that was too close for the time the show was made in, especially for a comedy.

Sometimes a movie or tv show plot is so stupid that only the stupid can understand it.

reply

The biggest goof is the one I call 'The Magic Tent.' In the final episode, a wounded soldier drives his tank into the compound, and it starts drawing enemy fire. Klinger erects a tent over the tank, hoping to fool the enemy into thinking it was gone. But the ruse didn't work, so Hawkeye ran into the tent, and drove the tank out and down to the garbage dump.

Here's the error: The tank that drove INTO camp was an M24 Chaffee light tank. The tank that drove OUT of the camp was an M4 Sherman medium tank. Other than the fact that they're both tanks, they look almost nothing alike.

The only conclusion: Klinger's magic tent changed the Chaffee into a Sherman.

- What are you gonna do, when the world catches on?

reply

I am not sure I'm remembering this right. Correct me if I'm wrong. (And my memory is so vague I can't even remember what season.) When MASH started being released on DVD (late '90s?) I bought them all as they were released and watched them, and haven't seen them since. Memory getting a bit faulty.

Anyway, there was that episode where they got the bathtub and the whole camp was queueing up outside the tent for a chance at a bath. Everybody was wearing regular daily clothing, Winchester was out in his bathrobe, type of thing. So, weather was probably at least 65 degrees outside, maybe warmer.

Either the episode directly preceding it, or the one directly following it, was a winter episode with everyone running around in parkas!

(Now that I'm thinking about this, I'm definitely going to have to find these episodes and watch them again.)

reply

You are correct, there were two back to back episodes showing the extreme weather conditions they experienced during the war, but the two situations don't really have to be seen as having happened literally a week apart from each other.

reply

One also needs to look at the real history of the war, as I've reiterated time and again. In December 1950, the Chinese had just recently intervened and the UN forces were just starting their long retreat from just south of Manchuria, a retreat which wouldn't end until April some 75-100 miles south of the 38th parallel. It wouldn't be until July that those troops would once again occupy the territory that would allow the 4077th to be stationed near Ouijanbu; so the pilot episode should be reading "1951, 100 years ago."

As for the rest, I guess one can assume that the MASH production team had no more knowledge of when the series would end than the UN-US Far East Command had of when their war would end. At least one was historical and follows a recognized timeline; I can't say the same for the other.

Nothing to lose sleep or count sheep over.

reply