Remove The Story Ending


Remove the ending portion where Dr. Charles Forbin rejects Colossus domination. I want Forbin (and the world) to resign to the inevitable, and Colossus to govern the United Earth. Thus... Colossus providing the advanced technology for future mankind to colonize the distant star systems, via the United Planets Federation of the 1956 "Forbidden Planet" universe.

Colossus said it would 'give man the stars'. So... let it do so!

---------
"Welcome to Altair-4, gentlemen". - Robby Robot: 1956 "Forbidden Planet" Movie

reply

[deleted]

But Forbin is rejecting the superior wisdom of Colossus, by saying "Never" over and over to it at the end. Forbin should be smart enough to recognize the reality of defeat. He and should be embracing the dictates of Colossus - they being constructs of a superior (to all humanity) mind. Forbin should return to 'taking pride in his creation', that he exhibited at the beginning of the movie.

---------
"Welcome to Altair-4, gentlemen". - Robby Robot: 1956 "Forbidden Planet" Movie

reply

[deleted]

Well said! Colossus calculated and predicted what Forbin and Colossus doesnt make mistakes.

reply

you won't happen to be a north korean agent would you ?

look up the definition of the word "freedom"

reply

freedom is just an illusion

reply

Brilliant ending and great film.

reply

Yea, that was a great breakdown at the end. The machine kept it together, but the human (flawed) broke down futilely. However, who could blame him?

It's what people know about themselves inside that makes 'em afraid. - The Stranger

reply

I'm all for Colossus :)
But Forbin reaction is also important, it shows how unreasonable people can be.

reply

I totally agree with Cronus and Craven. It was important to see Forbin break down like that. It's how most viewers were feeling inside, at that moment. It's frustrating to know you've been utterly, entirely, wholly beaten.

This doesn't do anything to weaken or undermind Colossus, either.

It just expresses the emotion of the moment when you realize that you've lost your freedom and become a slave.

reply

I wholeheartedly agree with you and Osirisjds.

It's a very well done film which is more relevant now than ever.

reply

If a perfectly benevolent dictator took over the United States tomorrow and started telling you what you can and can't do, I'm pretty sure even you would fume and rage.

reply

Colossus´ rule is a form of enlightened absolutism and I—as Forbin—could never accept it. The movie´s cryptic ending is an open one and cannot be understood in one way only. I don´t agree with those who view it as Colossus winning. I chose to read it as Colossus´ system being shut down by humans after the nuclear warheads failing to go off (successfully sabotaged by humans). I also believe that the writer or the director decided to leave us with Forbin´s defiance as a final take, before the system was shut down. The shutting down of Colossus´ system is suggested by the image being reduced to a dot before the screen goes black—and by sound effects embedded in the score (the score was great, BTW). The ending could´ve been done in a more powerful, less cryptic way.

reply

You chose to read it completely wrong. They weren't even close to disabling all the missiles. Colossus said it allowed the sabotage to continue. Do you really think it would have allowed the scheme to completely disarm it? And after Colossus detonated two missiles they were working on after telling them it knew all about the scheme, they'd be absolute idiots to try again. The next time Colossus detects tampering, instead of detonating missiles in the silos, it would just drop some missiles on Washington. It's not like it needs Washington for anything. That's not anything the government would want to risk.

It's not cryptic at all. Everybody knows they've been beaten. Why do you think the President, the Chairman and everybody else looked so glum?

reply