MovieChat Forums > If.... (1969) Discussion > Mrs. Kemp in dormitory

Mrs. Kemp in dormitory


What is the significance of Mrs. Kemp wandering nude through the dormitory while
everyone else is someplace else?

reply

Good question. I wondered the same thing. My interpretation is that it is supposed to symbolize that she is stuck in "the system" but secretly she wants to be "free", here symbolized by her walking around naked. She does this as a simple act of defiance. This is also somewhat backed up by the scene where she is eating with the crusaders and they are offering her everything off the table and doting on her, as if they can sense she is one of them. At first I thought they just had school boy crushes on her (she is an attractive older woman), but I think it is more than that. They can sense she also doesn't like the system, and so they feel a kinship with her. That's my take anyway.

reply

You have summed it up exactly. Said it in a way that no-one can improve upon.

reply

Glad I wasn't out to lunch on that one. ;) I'd be interested to hear your (or others') thoughts on it also though, this is a very complex film and I believe there are several meanings in every scene/action.

reply

You might include a loveless marriage, for her at least.

reply

Ah yes, a good point, for sure.

reply

I'd go along with your nudity/freedom symbolism interpretation, but I'd disagree on the later scene. I see no kinship or doting with the boys at the table; they are clearly mocking her and in the way that only adolescent boys can ever really manage, such a way that nobody could ever accuse them of having done anything wrong. That's one of the few moments in the film where I have no sympathy for the Crusaders; they are beastly to Mrs Kemp, as if she doesn't already have enough to be depressed about!

reply

Well said, I will have to watch it again with your thoughts in mind.

reply

My first instinct was that she was merely acting out a forbidden fantasy -- doing something naughty while the boys were outside playing. "If they only knew what I was doing in here..." -- that sort of thing.

As I recall, however, at the end of that sequence, she looked over her shoulder and gave the audience a pitiable expression of hopelessness: "this is what my life has come down to." The sadness on her face was sobering. It was a good way of showing that there were human beings whose souls were being crushed by the same system that gave us "Run In The Corridor!" and "Out of my way, scum!"

Running around nude might be shocking in itself, but that over-the-shoulder gaze at the audience showed that she was begging the audience not to judge her. That might be the only adventure she can allow herself as the wife of Mr. Kemp, the man who played the recorder in bed before going to sleep.

reply

Obviously unhappy and uncomfortable- Mick.shouldn't have baited her. I suspect she secretly loathed the place as much as he did.

reply