Shagal


This may have already been touched on somewhere on this board, but has anyone seen or read any interviews where Polanski addresses the self-deprecating Jewish humour in this film? Sure it's the 60s and our overly drastic, PC sensibilities were not in place, but also the second World War was pretty fresh in everyone's mind at this time (many were still finding out exactly what had happened in Nazi concentration camps). Were the film directed by a non-Jew, then I could understand it as a product of its time sort of thing, but the fact that Polanski saw so much anti-semitism first-hand, are we to assume that this is social commentary by way of conveying to the non-Jewish world how Jews feel they are portrayed? Or was Polanski at the time maybe having trouble with his own heritage? I've always wondered about it. Certainly it makes for a good old fashion kind of comedy, and the Brits get their share of the jabbing as well, which suits the goofy-Hammer Horror mood of the film. But it has always sat a little awkward with me (along with the fact that they find German vampires in Transylvania). Maybe it can just be choked up to the same thing as seinfeld, or john stewart, that Jews like poking fun at themselves (well then again all comedians now-a-days can only make fun of their own ethnicities, to joke about anyone else's is rascist.... anyhow, maybe someone more informed can fill me in.

reply

I don't think this really answers your questions but its a good read.

http://books.google.com/books?id=QHg7m_ESR54C&pg=PA99&lpg=PA99 &dq=roman+polanski+interview+Vampire+Killlers+jewish&source=we b&ots=yI6xWac3of&sig=jgELZ-T8trClLnTvyCgVOv9IaY0&hl=en&amp ;sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=6&ct=result#PPA99,M1

reply

It's my opinion that Polanski is like a runaway train as far as idealism in cinema goes. Others can make self-deprecating Jewish humor because most of it's carefully orchestrated for conditioning of one sort of another. I feel when someone like Polanski does it -- a man who has turned over one too many rocks in his day -- the powers-that-be (no not the Jews) start squirming in their pants.

However you crack it up, people like Polanski, Gibson, Gilliam etc. all have special rules who apply to them as far as movies go, they've all showed they are against evil and apparently someone took notice. That's just my opinion though.


"Confess quickly! If you hold out too long you could jeopardize your credit rating."

reply

I have noticed there seems to be several 'archetypes' in jewish/yiddish humor, and one is the 'guy you don't want in charge' character; remember Mel Brooks' Governor in 'blazing saddles' or president scroob in 'spaceballs'? There is a true comic appeal in yiddish humor when it comes to idiots-in-charge, and shagal is just another example....he covets the maid, he charges too much, he avoids responsibility, is cowardly, etc. and there is a profound universal dread of the guy in charge not being 100% good guy, yet a realistic knowledge that no person can be so constantly.

reply