MovieChat Forums > Fando y Lis (1972) Discussion > high contrast B+W - transfer or creative...

high contrast B+W - transfer or creative choice?


I just watched the Anchor Bay DVD (on a 52" LCD) and I was wondering after reading some complaints here, is the high contrast look something Jodorowsky did on purpose, or is it a bad transfer? I didn't notice the other transfer problems people talked about here, no pan & scan, and as sharp as I would expect a 16mm film to look.

I'd like to think the high contrast was on purpose. While normally I like B&W's technically correct rich range of tones, here I thought the high contrast, with big chunks of images falling into a black (or white) hole was perfect for a work that is dealing with archetypes. the rocks and rubble shot this way looked almost like static, a fractal chaos, perfect for a journey through a chaotic world, I loved the way the figures seemed to constantly be forming from and dissolving into the background visual noise.

I know shooting high contrast was on purpose in Aronofsky's "Pi" and effective for different reasons, so I'd like to know from people who have seen other versions of Fando y Lis if it had the same graphic high contrast look.

If they ever invent a time machine I'm going to the premiere/riot of this film (right after a Velvet Underground concert at the Factory and going to see who was on the grassy knoll).

*
Downloads of Ambient & Neo-classical Music : http://music.download.com/dj_dreamstream

reply

Well, I'd argue that Aronofsky did it simply because he made most of that movie ripping off Shinya Tsukamoto's Tetsuo: The Iron Man, but...yeah.

Anyway, it seemed appropriate to me as well.

I certainly know about intention though.

reply

I wouldn't say that he ripped it off... are there any proofs for that?

_____________________
--- BE TROLL 2!!! ---

www.myspace.com/anzycpethian

reply

Watch the two movies back to back. Tell me he didn't rip it off.

reply

The fantoma version is also high-contrast bw. Although my personal preference is usually for more middle-ground - it really works for FyL and is beautiful.

reply