MovieChat Forums > Tôkyô nagaremono (1966) Discussion > Mixed feelings about this movie

Mixed feelings about this movie


(My opinion obviously...you don't have to agree)
I found it really visually interesting but felt like the plot and writing was near-braindead. There's no consistency or logic, no real characterization or any kind of consideration of plot besides the basic framework of "these guys are in a gang and they shoot each other". Half the movie was just people getting phone calls and often things just completely made no sense ("my range is ten meters"?). I don't think the viewer should have to make a diagram just to figure out what the basic events of a movie are...

In terms of cinematography and everything, it was often extremely well done. I just felt like the filmmaker was imaginative enough to create these visually really great and stylized settings but had almost no sense of narrative or cohesion. This is rated higher than I expected

reply

I just finished watching this and came away with the same conclusion, a film that looks very good, but poorly edited and a bit muddled.

reply

I just finished watching the film, a little over a year since you posted your comment, but I agree 100% with your opinion. There is no need for me to write anything else. I feel the same as you. Great comment! I rated it a "6"

reply

I agree, though I watched a poor print so the cinematography was rather watered out. By far the weakest Suzuki I have seen.

My 105 favorite films - http://www.imdb.com/list/5pdE8_ZEh0Y/?publish=save

reply

Wow. I agree with everyone here. I actually fell asleep during this movie. And I didn't fall asleep during Hollywoodland or Good Luck and Good Night. The style didn't do a damn thing for me. Yes, I found the editing sloppy too. Like another poster who disliked this flick, I also found most characterizations and situations forced. I feel 7.1 out of 10 rating is 4 points too high.

My sig: why do almost all movies on imdb have a "worst movie ever!" thread?

reply

"I found it really visually interesting but felt like the plot and writing was near-braindead. There's no consistency or logic, no real characterization or any kind of consideration of plot besides the basic framework of "these guys are in a gang and they shoot each other". Half the movie was just people getting phone calls and often things just completely made no sense ("my range is ten meters"?)."

Yes, but wasn't that rather the point?

I appreciated the film's stupidity and anti-logic. That's what makes it fun. Although I think Branded to Kill is way more hilarious, surreal, incoherent (in a good way), interesting, and memorable, and is easily the better film.


My Top 50 Films:
http://www.imdb.com/list/Bw65XZIpkH8/

reply

I agree. The plot of this film is just all over the place. How is one actually supposed to fihure out what's happening is beyond me.

reply