just mean...
who's meaner the grinch or scrooge?
A stranger's just a friend you've never met.
ok I guess no one has ever read christmas bokks then...
A stranger's just a friend you've never met.
[deleted]
MovieChat Forums > How the Grinch Stole Christmas! (1966) Discussion > just mean...
Scrooge.
sharethe grinch wanted to steal christmas, scrooge just wanted to ignore it,
"So, Lone Star, now you see that evil will always triumph because good is dumb." -Dark Helmet
i'd have to say scrooge. the grinch was only intentionally mean to people during christmas, while scrooge was mean to people all year, all the time
WHY IS WHO?
Definately Scrooge because the Grinch left the Whos alone for 50 years, and he just took their things, Scrooge was a terror to people every single day of the year, and he made sure people didn't get things they wanted, or for the most of it rather the things they needed.
shareDefinitely Scrooge. He was just a nasty guy all year round.
Nobody does W.C. Fields singing "Mama Told Me Not to Come" better than Paul Frees.
[deleted]
I like them both, The whole Christmas thing is stupid and fake.
shareSome good points are made above. But, let me add this:
With Scrooge, we know how he acted on the other 364 days of the year.
With the Grinch, we have no idea. (I don't think? Unless perhaps we do from other stories and not necessarily this film?)
So, it's impossible to make a fair comparison.