MovieChat Forums > A Patch of Blue (1965) Discussion > Do Black People Like this Movie?

Do Black People Like this Movie?


I'm just curious.

I saw it years ago, and I thought Sidney Poitier was to die for! Even though I was sort of pulling for them to end up together, I thought it probably wouldn't work out; not because they were of different races, but because Gordon surely couldn't have been intellectually stimulated by Selena for very long. He felt protective of her, and was taken by her innocence and upbeat personality, and he might have been attracted to her physically; but he was cultured and well-educated, so it seems like in a long-term match, he would've become bored with her. Or maybe not...if you believe opposites attract, you wouldn't be able to pry them apart with a crowbar, because they sure were that...

de gustibus non est disputandum

reply

I always just equated it to Romeo & Juliet with the different families being the times, society, race, blindness and Shelley Winters'all conspiring to keep them apart.

reply

I am Black and I love this movie. The whole cast gives stellar performances.

reply

Some of my first memories(born 1964) are of this movie. Shelley Winters scared the holy crap out of me. I distinctly remember the flashback when Salina gets blinded with a thrown booze bottle (if I remember correctly). I have watched it many times since and find it to be an incredibly touching film. They really don't make movies like this anymore. Way too much dialogue and character developement for todays crowd. I highly recomend this movie to anyone looking to see how beautiful and life changing a friendship can be.

reply

I'm black and I enjoyed this movie

reply

The movie is a little sappy for my taste, but I'm aware of the times in which it was made. Poitier is superb, as is Hartman (an actress I don't know). But, the stand out performance, to me, is Winters. She does coarse and vulgar so well.

reply

Everyone who thinks the movie ends so well might want to read the book.

reply

[deleted]

I loved the movie and I loved the way the two were not typical anything, just two people who were affectionate towards each other

if it were up to me I'd chose to speak like Humphrey Bogart, but....it isn't

reply

Well, I'm white, but gay, so I have quite a bit of experience with prejudice!

I loved the movie - I love Sidney Poitier - He is suave, gorgeous and a wonderful actor. I also liked how none of the crowd responded to Rose-Ann confronted Gordon and Selina. In fact, they looked down on her like she was every bit of the white trash she was...

It was a very poignant story...

‘Six inches is perfectly adequate; more is vulgar!' (Prime of Miss Jean Brodie Re: An open window).

reply

I'm black and I like this movie. It has two of my favorite actors - Sidney Poitier and Shelley Winters.

Life: An STD with 100% mortality rate
I Gave Up Trying to Find Intelligence on IMDB

reply

I'm a black female, and I truly LOVE this movie. My husband watched it for the first time with me last night, and he loved it, too. It's the kind of movie that gives you residual feelings...long after the movie's over. We talked about it well into the night. Also, I never know EH took her own life, that makes me kinda tear up again. She was so perfect in the role.

reply

Do any non-Black People like this movie? Just curious.

reply

I'm a white woman and I love it. I first saw it as a little girl and it has always been right up there with my favorites.. I guess I saw it a little as someone else indicated...a sort of Romero and Juliet story.
Funny thing was that because of the way that I was raised I really thought of it more as "what can he see in her"...but as I got older I saw so many ways to see it ...and thought how beautiful it came across that he was the only person that noticed her and saw that she desperately needed help despite the climate of the times and his own disadvantages..This is what life should be for us all.
A wonderful movies.

reply

I think you hit the nail on the head with your viewpoint after you got older. That is the essence of the movie and what makes it wonderful. It's really not any kind of "Romeo and Juliet" story. Romeo and Juliet is a story of "romantic" love. This movie is not about romantic love; its about a handicapped young woman who is living in an abusive and dysfunctional home and thru a random meeting receives the uplifting assistance she needs from a man who happens to be Black, which ironically occurs in the middle of the 1960's civil rights period while her blindness doesn't allow her to see race.

The love demonstrated here is principally the love for the worthiness and humanity of the handicapped among us, which is not a Romeo and Juliet kinda love.
We do get wiser as we get older. Excellent analysis on your part.

reply

I'm black and I first saw the film when I was 9 or 10 years old. My parents often took me to see what were considered "adult" films at the time. I also saw "Days of Wine and Roses" and "Hud." My folks whispered to each other and groaned during the picture. Driving home they let it out, my father mostly:
"You KNOW somebody white wrote that &$##@. Hell, if I slap a white woman in public in front of a buncha white people, they'd tear me into liitle pieces!"

"Now his brother did speak some truth. Let white folks take care of their own and for God's sake, don't bring no blind white gal into your crib again!"
"Look, I'm glad Sidney gets plenty of work. Somebody like James Edwards just came along too soon."
"You think Sidney gets paid as much as Steve McQueen?"
(much laughter)"Man, he don't get paid as much as Tab Hunter!"
I saw the film for the first time since then last week. I got caught up in the story, but it was quite naive. But the wonderful performances overcame the flaws. Great way for Wallace Ford to cap his career.
"May I bone your kipper, Mademoiselle?"

reply

Generally, those were pretty perceptive comments from your parents back in 1965.

reply

My mother especially, turned me into a movie nut. Some Saturdays when she wasn't working, we would actually go to three different theaters and see three films. In 1965 or '66, this probably didn't cost much more than $30, even if you add our bus fare.

"May I bone your kipper, Mademoiselle?"

reply

[deleted]

This movie is absolutely one of my all time favorites and I am a Black 57 year old female. I would have been ten when this movie was out and it always seemed like it was "in the old days". Shelly Winters in this movie was phenomenal! Instead of making me hate her guts for being racist, my first viewing of her performing made me a huge fan. In my opinion, she is one of greatest actresses ever!

reply

As a middle aged Caucasian man born in the turbulent 1960's with a rather forward thinking mother, I remember being allowed to stay up late three times (at least, there were possibly more), one being for this movie, another for the T.V. premiere of "Gone With the Wind", and lastly, for the entire week of "Roots". I'll never forget my mother telling my siblings and I that we were going to watch something very important that explained what racism was, and while the other themes of "A Patch of Blue" (child abuse/prostitution) went over my head, the theme of racism from both sides stuck with me. I was thunderstruck by not only Shelley Winters' abuse of Elizabeth Hartman, but her nastiness to Sidney Poitier in the final confrontation scene.

As an adult, I began to see more, such as the reactions from Poitier's friend, and putting it into perspective with the times, got to see it from a different angle. As one other poster pointed out, Winters' character was definitely the lowest of the low of white trash, and to see a black man being better spoken and doing better than her brought out her hatred in truck loads. Shelley profusely apologized to Sidney for the words she had to use, but he needed no apology, knowing that it was a part of the script and a very important message to convey how wrong racism is, and how vile any type of prejudice is.

For that matter, I was also fairly young when I saw "The Diary of Anne Frank" for which Shelley won her first Oscar, and being on the second film of hers I had seen, had an idea of who she was only from "A Patch of Blue". Mrs. Van Daan is far more decent than her character here, but becomes nagging and calculating as the tensions between her and her husband and the Franks becomes too grave. By the time she had the recurring role on "Roseanne", I had read her autobiographies, realized how seriously liberal she was, and admired her bravery for taking on such a role. As for Mr. Poitier, his film work has been so brilliant, making me wish I could have seen him on stage, and all the way through seeing the Sean Combs revival of "A Place in the Sun", kept thinking to myself about how that performance was so greatly influenced by the gentility and humility of one of the greatest actors of the past century, and never even once associated it with the color of his skin.

"Great theater makes you smile. Outstanding theater may make you weep."

reply

I am formerly known as HillieBoliday....Member since May 2006

As an African-Woman, this is one of my favorites. Even without the conflict of color and racism; the back story of care and compassion for some one who is mistreated, oppressed and abused...Is what has always resonated for me.

Growing up and being raised by a loving, Christian mother who would take on the whole world to protect me and my 4 brothers; I was absolutely appalled by the evil and vile treatment Selina received from her mother. With that being said....I totally understood and approved of Salina falling in love with Gordon...Who wouldn't (regardless of color/race) fall in love with such an angel as Gordon?!

Salina, inspite of the abuse she suffered and the adversities she had to endure; she some how retained her sweetness, kindness and the ability to respond in kind to someone (she could not see) who was willing to help her.

"OOhhhooo....I'M GON' TELL MAMA!"

reply