MovieChat Forums > The Collector (1965) Discussion > This film needs a new score

This film needs a new score


I find that the music did not fit the mood of the scenes very often.

reply

You mean there should have been accordian music or bagpipes? You are a half-wit.

You can't hold a candle to Gulbenkian.

reply

Well, irrespective of his beautiful "Zhivago" score, Maurice Jarre's music DOES get on your nerves from time to time - it's too often the same melodic modulations, over and over. (His score for "Topaz" is another striking example of rather obtrusive soundtrack music.)

Personally, I think someone like John Barry would have been a far better choice for "The Collector".

reply

What you're saying is that you don't think the score suited the movie. I disagree. Jarre captures the essence of the movie perfectly: it's melancholic and has a powerful emotional resonance that reinforces the movie's strong thematic elements -- desperation, despair and depression. Just listen to the music right from the opening scene where you see Freddy chasing after butterflys in the field with his net; he's running carefree in an open field on a bright summer's day, filled with alacrity. But you know that despite this seemingly innocuous scene, it actually presages something quite sinister. Because the music tells us so.

You can't hold a candle to Gulbenkian.

reply

I agree, The Collector's score seemed obtrusive to me. Maybe it just hasn't aged well, but at times I was actually reminded of Carl Stalling compositions from old Warner Bros. cartoons that set a tongue-in-cheek pastoral mood for PorkyPig/Foghorn Leghorn.

reply

I was saying much the same thing to my friend while we watched this. The score seemed rather generic and much too upbeat for the subject matter. No score would have been better than the rather bouncy instrumentals here.

reply

If anybody's a half-wit here you are. What a shockingly rude idiot.

reply

Oh, go back to playing your harmonica.

You stupid, clumsy labouring-boy.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

You know nothing about film music .Mr Mark

reply

I haven't seen the movie in a while, but the score is one of the things I do remember vividly.
You are right.

reply

The score is fine and effective. IMHO it's overused in the film.

reply

I heartily agree. The music was weak and ineffectual throughout.

reply

[deleted]


Hahaha! The Maurice Jarre score was absolutely perfect for this film; I don't think I have EVER heard anyone make that ludicrous statement... This soundtrack fit "The Collector" like 'Tubulor Bells' fit "The exorcist..."
"IMdB; where 14 year olds can act like jaded 40 year old critics...'

reply

This soundtrack fit "The Collector" like 'Tubulor Bells' fit "The exorcist..."


Although the intro piano music from "Tubular Bells" was used as the closing theme in The Exorcist, that music didn't serve as the film's soundtrack.

reply

Just watched the film and I do agree with the folks who find it overscored by Jarre, and with music that was not appropriate for what was going on at the time. It would have been better with more silence and sparing us all of the bad musical underpinning. Wyler should have used Bernard Hermann. His sensibility would have been perfect.

reply

I finally finished watching the film today and agree that the music is over scored. 50 years ago, it probably wouldn't have seemed so bad.

reply

I generally like Jarre's scores, but I have to admit on this and some of his other ones I've heard, that the music would begin and I'd half-way expect it to lead into "Lara's Theme" from Dr. Zhivago. There's just a similarity or repetition in the instrumentation and score that is often there, to my ears at least.

reply

I agree Herrmann would have been perfect.

I think the Jarre score was trying to be weird and ironic at times-- but it never seems to fully work.

reply

It was made in 1965. Both leads are now in their late 70s.

The music was the king of mood music used in drama at that time.

reply