MovieChat Forums > 8½ (1963) Discussion > Take my 'I'm a cinephile, not a movie bu...

Take my 'I'm a cinephile, not a movie buff' membership card away


After years of hearing about it, finally watched 8 1/2. A comedy it is not. A satirical look at the life of a director, intermixed with tales of his personal life, eh. As someone who grew up on films by guys like Woody Allen and later David Lynch, I now know where a lot if their inspiration came from. I also admire Fellini's eye for beauty, much like my favorite director, Bergman.

All this being said, the movie fell flat. Please, no comments about me not getting it. I thoroughly understood and even championed his ideas, that we are all haunted by mistakes, lost loves and taking some for granted. I even admired his honestly in telling his wife and his lovers that a woman can not change a man, especially one who draws so much of his inspiration from his own experiences. My problem is that the intentionally convoluted story, just isn't that interesting. It's repetitive and tame in many ways. His reality is more riviting than his fantasy and this troubled me.

In the end, I will chalk this up to being groundbreaking at the time and much like the plot, playing of the director's past successes, warranted or not.

reply

I hated it, too. Though I did love the camerawork.












--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply

It truly does comfort me to know I am not alone. My father has been raving about it for years and while we normally see eye to eye, I guess it's just one of those movies, I don't get the allure of.

reply

YOU ARE NOT ALONE. lol

I agree with 100% of what you said.

You seem to have a similar taste in movies, can you list some of your favorites? Its not often I see someone that I see eye to eye with in movie prefrences. I'm curious as to what your favorite films are.

reply

12 Angry Men
Seventh Seal
Jaws
The Killer
Oldboy
Seven Samurai
Silence of the Lambs

Just a couple

reply

[deleted]

I loved it (9/10), but I can sympathize with your feeling more generally. I didn't like Raging Bull, for instance, and for most cinephiles this is grounds for card revocation as well. To each his or her own.

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

Aside from the cinematography, I despise Raging Bull. I dislike many of the films that are the creme de la creme, but usually because I think there are simply better films by the same director, actor, etc.

That being said I just watched Tokyo Story and while I may disagree with Sight & Sound ranking it #1 all-time, I honestly can't argue their reasoning.

reply

i also loved 8 1/2. i really love fellini. i didn't expect to. ran through his films last winter.

reply