Armageddon Factor


Easily my favorite of season 16, Key to Time
From the war between the worlds that wasn't, to the evil Shadow, to the Black Guardian
The way even K-9 was turned to the dark side was fun, seeing the Doctor pushing him down the tunnel was a real LOL moment
Just as I felt Mary was coming into the persona of Romana, arguing with the Doctor, standing up to him, as a Time Lady, I learn, however, she left of her own free will, Bad decision, Mary, (R.I.P.) a beautiful lady......

I also learn that Laila Ward, not only is replacing her, as Romana but no regen scene... BBC must have been p.o'd at her(Mary)
Somehow I thought Laila was much younger, than Mary, must be the make-up
So
we have a married couple to be on the TARDIS, I must say I am curious how they play the scenes together now....

Had I been in charge, I would have moved heaven and earth to write a story wherein Romana returns to Gallifrey, having completed her mission, and Leela returns to the TARDIS

reply

Well, that's an...erm...unusual perspective, but it's good to hear refreshing views. I'm delighted you enjoyed it so much, but 'easily my favourite of season 16' is not a sentence that's typically associated with viewing Armageddon Factor. Good for you! I very much enjoy how it starts, but once the middle gets bogged down in the endless time loops with John Woodvine (and prior to that, I had thought I could watch John Woodvine forever - this story sadly disabused me of that notion), and then we go into the finish with the very silly barrow-boy Time Lord Drax scenes, and the shrinking, it's all got a bit too silly. And then Tom does his boggle eyes, and the end undermines the entire premise of the whole season in the first place. Princess Astra is brilliant, and is rightly called back the next year. But rather as a final microcosm of the whole season, it starts off very well, but eventually collapses into silliness at the end.

Just a painted face on a trip down suicide row

reply

interesting as I see Astra as a non player and only there for a love interest, I wonderif Tom had anything to do with her playing Romana

reply

Very interesting, indeed. The Armageddon Factor is my least favorite of the Key to Time season, mainly because of how drawn out it is.

At the beginning of the next story, Destiny of the Daleks, Romana does have a bit of a regeneration scene, but it doesn't make any sense whatsoever to everything we know about regeneration. However, in the story "The Lying Old Witch in the Wardrobe," it's revealed that the Romana we see in Destiny of the Daleks is actually the TARDIS, who has trapped Romana inside her wardrobe and taken on the form of Princess Astra. Basically Romana I knows her regeneration is near due to 'exposure of chronotron particles' and decides to go to the wardrobe to change into something. There she meets Iraj/The TARDIS, who tricks her and freezes her in time. Iraj/The TARDIS has a crush on the Doctor and transforms into many different bodies, eventually tricking the Doctor into accepting Princess Astra's form. After the events of Destiny of the Daleks, Iraj/the TARDIS returns to the wardrobe where Romana I is still frozen, having realized that the Doctor only wants a companion that he can show off to. She disappears and unfreezes Romana I, who regenerates immediately into Princess Astra's form, since that was the last person she saw while she was frozen in time.

reply

A story that goes to extraordinarily convoluted lengths to explain something that absolutely didn't need explaining. ;)

So this is permanence, love's shattered pride.
What once was innocence, turned on its side.

reply

Pretty much, but it does fit in with the personality of the TARDIS, as she's similar there to how she is in "The Doctor's Wife."

reply

True, unfortunately.

I like Gaiman - I'm currently enjoying his Ocean at the End of the Lane - but we could have done without The Doctor's Wife.

So this is permanence, love's shattered pride.
What once was innocence, turned on its side.

reply

I know this isn't what you're saying but

Just as I felt Mary was coming into the persona of Romana, arguing with the Doctor, standing up to him, as a Time Lady, I learn, however, she left of her own free will, Bad decision, Mary, (R.I.P.)


reads kind of like Mary was assassinated for not continuing in the role of Romana 

https://soundcloud.com/rhythm-n-weird

New song "Where was I?"

reply

They're repeating the episode now! I haven't seen it in years! It so reminds me of "Blake's 7" From the music to the names of the characters like Drax, Merak, & Shapp! If I don't look at it, I would think Avon is about to turn the corner and take over! 

- http://scifiblogs3.blogspot.com/2011/01/introduction-to-blakes-7.html

- - http://www.childrenofrassilon.com/blakes-7.html - Blake's 7 Homage - -

- http://scifiblogs3.blogspot.com/2011/08/children-of-rassilon-kapla.html -

- http://scifiblogs3.blogspot.com/2011/09/doctor-who-other-sci-fi-program-comments.html -

- Jamie/Fiero425 - http://www.childrenofrassilon.com/doctor-who.html -

reply

knowing Avon he would have to leap dramatically around the corner in a kung fu stance 

https://soundcloud.com/rhythm-n-weird

New song "Where was I?"

reply

I don't think it's as bad as it's made out but it has a lot of flaws, others have mentioned how it gets drawn out because of the time loop which is also a waste of John Woodvine.

It has some good ideas but Merak is the biggest plonker in the observable universe, OK I can understand that a civilisation on the brink of total collapse will end up with people rushed through training and promoted way above their station. But he's so vacuous and totally obsessed with Astra. Davyd Harries' Shap is good in most of it as a foul for first the Marshal then the Doctor but he ruins it when he gets shot.

Overall 5/10 but still worth watching.

reply

It is such an oddly constructed story, the Marshall starts out as a major player (even though he was technically a pawn) but then he just ends up put out of action for much of the rest of the story and hardly ends up matter in the end, then you get Drax showing up halfway through... it's like someone took two completely different stories and just kind of jammed them together

https://soundcloud.com/rhythm-n-weird

New song "Where was I?"

reply

Davyd Harries' Shap is good in most of it as a foul for first the Marshal then the Doctor but he ruins it when he gets shot.
Shap and Drax made it worth watching. I do like Drax's introduction which comes across like he's tunneled through from another BBC series. 

reply



https://soundcloud.com/rhythm-n-weird

New song "Where was I?"

reply

It's the way it's shot that makes it come across that way.

reply