My thoughts afte a 2nd viewing


I just saw this movie again, with my wife as the opening film for a French New Wave "festival" (11 films over two 4 day weekends at a Modern Art Musuem in Fort Worth). My wife hated it by the way, the phrase "you owe me" came up on the ride home. She mentioned that she had given up on enjoying the film before it started because the pre-show speaker said that it was boring, without a plot, and that, quoting Roger Ebert, "there were no answers." I think she might of given it a chance if the speaker wasn't so glib about the qualities of the film.

These are my thoughts regarding the film after seeing it on the big screen:

1. The difference between emotional truth and factual truth with regard to memory.
2. The differences between the two people’s emotional truth for the same factual event.
3. Factual truth, such as a sculpture or two people walking, can lead to an emotional lie or misconception.
4. Proust: When two people that used to love each other meet again there is a death between them.
5. Choosing between a life of security and a life with love.
6. The difference and similarity between different increments of time, i.e. “not now,…” next week or next month or next year.
7. Different factual events that lead to the same emotional truth.
8. Changing your emotions, feelings, with regard to a emotional truth, event, and having to reconcile that with the person you shared the emotional truth with.
9. Finding a connecting points between emotion based memories for multiple people while attempting to reconcile those memories with the factual memories, i.e. a photograph.
10. ...It has some funny moments

My Ratings: http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=19694112

reply

hey, cool. i was there, too. a second helping for me as well. i liked the film a bit less the second time... a few sections felt forced and even silly. i didn't feel that way the first time around. it didn't help that the film was turned up way too loud, either. some of the sequences are absolutely stunning, though. resnais' night and fog, hiroshima mon amour and the american uncle are three of my favorite films of all time. this one has now become a curiosity piece. and i'm glad my wife was not able to go with me, or i'd have heard the same!



"Rampart: Squad 51."

reply

Which book of ISOLT is that Proust quote from?

cinemapedant.blogspot.com

reply

Probably the Fugitive or Time Regained (titles from the ‘Remembrance of Things Past’ set) I don’t remember exactly it’s been a couple years since I read it. It was one of the many ideas and lines that have stuck with me for the novel.

My Ratings: http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=19694112

reply

I'll have to re-read that passage. ISOLT of was an addictive experience for me as I read each book one after the other without a break in between.

cinemapedant.blogspot.com

reply