gerimd,
Eseentially you are arguing for a relatively positive, upbeat take on the film's ending. WHile I find optimism appealing, certainly when it is plausible, I can't share it for this film.
I think the issue exists in the central nature of Sandro's character. Claudia is all too aware, I would say right on through the film, but certainly after having discovered him with the actress, that she does not and should not trust him. Her being drawn to him does not contradict this realization, although she and perhaps objectively all of us think it should. Recognizing Claudia can and does know who Sandro is, if you will, and also be somewhat drawn to him is central to understanding this film.
But in the end, are we to make of his patting his head as a sign of their going to live happily ever after? I think the answer to that is clearly no. I instead see the gesture as indicating that on one level she feels pity for him, pity that his nature is what it is, and that even the torment it causes him is not enough for him to change so fundamentally. But pity is not enough upon which to build a future.
Of course Claudia knows quite well that she has her own contradictions, and existential anxieties resulting from such recognition. That kind of self identification and knowledge, I think, is not enough for her to see Sandro as the same as her, or if you will as a soul mate. Hardly. The film ends, despite the gesture, with a great distance remaining between them. Sandro's own internal conflict does not lead to any resolution. He is in tears precisely because he recognizes this.
I do not necessarily feel that their relationship ends as the film does. Perhaps there will exist some lingering lack of willingness to end it. But in the end it goes nowhere.
reply
share