Was Benson A Racist....?


or just extremely horny? The guy struck me as more a sex fiend than anything else who was trying to kill Ralph because he wanted the competition out of the way not because the guy was black.

I guess I'm looking at this film from a 'modern' perspective but Ralph was just too noble to be believable. Here he is the only guy within a thousand miles of a stone cold fox who wants him and he's ready to hand her over to the first white man who comes along? I guess the black/white thing was so ingrained in Ralph that it was a line he wasn't able to cross even with no chance of censure.

The TCM description was misleading though because I expected Benson to be more a Bull Connor-type rather than an individual conflicted by what he wants and what is right. Wow, a fully three-dimensional character in a sci-fi movie mixed with a study on race relations. Radical concept and ahead of its time.

Solid movie that I'm glad I watched and I thankful to TCM for showing it tonight.

reply

I agree with your interpretation. Benson just wanted the girl. If he was truly a racist, he would have killed Ralph when he had the chance. Just before this movie, TCM showed "Five" which had a similar theme. The character Eric in that film WAS a racist and acted on it.

reply

I also agree with you guys. The description on my guide called Benson a "bigot". However, I didn't get that at all. He just seemed to be in competition over the girl. Race didn't seem to be a motive.

This movie was definitely ahead of it's time. But, some things were a bit distracting. Ralph's character would be viewed oddly by a modern audience. Even in 1959 you would think any man alone with any 21 year old woman for 2 months........use your imagination. So, his character came across as unbelievable. However, for the time, it must have been a ground breaking character development. Belafonte plays the role very well.

reply

Yes, the movie was ahead of it's time but because it was still made in it's time it was hamstrung by certain conventions. In 'real' life, Ralph and Ms. Crandall probably would have consummated their relationship without all dancing around but since it was made in the 50's the filmmakers still had to bow to the sensibilities of the time.

I wish I had watched 'Five' before this movie because the only reason I checked this out was because Belafonte was in it and wasn't expecting much more than that. I'm glad I was surprised because Inger Stevens ranks behind Simone Simon now on my list of classic screen beauties. Ms. Stevens was a true beauty and that smile was to die for. Too bad she died young but I'm grateful that I can go back and watch her other movies.

Thank you TCM!!

reply

I believe that the reviewer at TCM either did not watch this movie or only watched parts of it.
I think they were thinking of "Five."
If Benson was a racist then you would have to consider all the characters in this movie racists.

reply

SPOILERS.In a sense all of the characters were motivated by the racism of the fifties. Early in the movie when Inger Stevens Harry Belafonte's characters have problems relating to each other, because they are constrained racial taboos of the era even though, in the context of this film Jim Crow laws, John Stennis, Orval Faubus, lynch mobs, Dixiecrat's and northern county club racism are dead and gone with most of man kind, its culture and customs. It is interesting Belafonte's first instinct is to try to find someone for Ms. Stevens even though, for all his character know, he may be the only male alive on the planet.

Then Benson enters the scene, more country club bigot then pathological Ku Klux Klan racist, and, as often happened id real life, thing escalate and he and Belafonte are trying to kill each other in the empty streets.

SPOILER!! There may or may not be some significance it is Belafonte"s character who ends it all by putting down his gun.


TAG LINE: True genius is a beautiful thing, but ignorance is ugly to the bone.

reply

he wasn't a racist....he just hated black guys.

reply

[deleted]

I don't see him as an overt racist, but he certainly had a sense of entitlement.

reply

It was Belafonte who was the racist. Reluctant to be with a white woman.

reply