Or, maybe Boone and Dahl declined. Dahl (whom I saw at a private screening of Designing Woman co-hosted by Lauren Bacall four years ago) looked a bit frail then, so she simply might not be in good health at 87.
I keep forgetting that Arlene Dahl is still with us, but as you said Hobnob, she is probably gotten along in years. Pat Boone was in special features segment and I think he even did commentary on a NIGHT GALLERY episode he was in called "The Academy" where he wanted to take his troubled son in a military school and apparently, they stay there forever!
The worst commentary I ever heard was in THE GIANT BEHEMOTH, provided by Dennis Muren and Phil Tippet. Great special effects guys, but lousy commentators, film historians, etc. Of course, they mostly dismissed the movie, expect for the stop-motion, could not remember the name of the lead actor (Gene Evans) and even got some facts wrong in another movies. They thought that the elderly scientist in THE BEAST FROM 20,000 FATHOMS was the same actor who was in THEM! I will admit, there are similar characteristics in Cecil Kellaway and Edmund Gwenn, but Gwenn was actually an Oscar winner (MIRACLE ON 34TH STREET). They needed a historian, someone like Tom Weaver, to have been a participant.
On those Criterion Godzilla commentaries, I've only listed to GKOTM, and thought David Kalat did quite a good job.
I generally like the commentaries where they talk about the movie itself, certain scenes, etc. Listening to someone like Rudy Behlmer, while his Hollywood knowledge is second to none, he always goes off on a tangent and talks about an actor's LONG resume, while critical scenes in the movie are passing us by. The best commentary I've ever listened to was in METROPOLIS. I don't recall the narrator's name, but it was all about scenes in the movie, what it meant, (or could have meant) and how it was accomplished. No going off an tangents, or anything like that.
reply
share