MovieChat Forums > Vertigo (1958) Discussion > Absolutely nothing in this movie could'v...

Absolutely nothing in this movie could've happened (spoilers)

posted 2 years ago by [deleted]
3 replies | jump to latest

Vertigo may have been beautifully shot, but it had one of the most inane scripts of all time.

Let's take the famous tower scene when the suicide is faked. When "Madeleine" commits suicide, Scotty would have definitely seen the body right afterward or seen photographs of the real wife in an obit or newspaper headlines somewhere. There's no way that at some point, he wouldn't have come across something that informed him that there were actually two women.

[–] Otter (24464) 2 years ago

As for the corpse, well, there WAS a corpse. And it was dressed and styled the same way as Scotty's date, and it had fallen far enough to do serious damage to the head and face. And Scotty was out of his fucking mind at that point, so it's not like he was doing a lot of close rational observation.

But if the whole thing is impossible, that's actually part of the film's charm. It's dreamlike.

[–] WandererFromYs (2347) 3 months ago

It's mentioned during the hearing that fled the scene of the crime, so he didn't see the body right afterwards. Then he was catatonic for a period of time afterward, so he likely wouldve missed any newspaper articles about it, containing her real picture. He probably could've gotten ahold of the crime scene photos from old connections, but he just wasn't ready to deal with that.

[–] KingBob (2745) 22 days ago

The body fell from a pretty tall height, the face would have been completely splattered beyond recognition. Also Gavin made Judy look like his wife, he wouldn’t have known the difference.