MovieChat Forums > Smultronstället (1959) Discussion > Similar theme different approach to Kuro...

Similar theme different approach to Kurosawa's "Ikiru"


I find this interesting =D

reply

it's a universal theme. but hey, look at how many people know and recognize this theme and still turn out to be miserable *beep* in real life?

that's the human condition. like all great artists, bergman holds up a mirror to our faces.

reply

Yes, i recognized that too when i watched this film, i love both, Ikiru a little bit more, both still got a 10/10 for me, both are one of the greatest films ever

reply

The themes are same to a certain degree only.. Ikiru is how the man transforms from a cold, frigid being to one who enjoys the life. While Wild Strawberries shows a misunderstood man; one who does not express his warmth much to the others. This has a more complex philosophy than Ikiru which too is a great and wonderful film.

reply

and De Sica's Umberto D, the same theme, different country, more sad, a masterpiece

reply

They are playing back to back on TCM tonight

reply

I was rather reminded of "The Tokyo Story" and in general of Ozu´s cinema, The style and the pacing seem also to have more in common with Ozu than with Kurosawa.

It´s also curious how in both cases the stepdaughter has a prominent role, even more than the biological children. That same motif of the stepdaughter appears as well in Dreyer´s "Ordet".

reply