My problem was that it was on the Universal backlot
This is a pretty good picture, all in all. Yeah, there's some miscasting going on. March is too old; Gig Young is so old he shoulda been Gig Old. The cops are all pretty good; a lotta familiar faces. But it's a good story, good script, well-written.
The thing that just leaps out at me is that this is clearly - INCREDIBLY CLEARLY - filmed on Universal's back lot. It's called Colonial Street, and you have literally seen it 100 times. This movie, to The Twilight Zone, to Leave It to Beaver, The Munsters, Psycho, right up to the aptly named Desperate Housewives.
It's that angle of the bend in the road, and those short little lampposts. They're dead giveaways. It bugs me that a high-budget picture like this, with two big leads, would cheap out by doing this. Not being a Desperate Housewives fan, all I could think about was The Twilight Zone's The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street.
I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.