MovieChat Forums > The Caine Mutiny (1954) Discussion > Help me find a similar film... court mar...

Help me find a similar film... court martial at sea.



Hi all.
I need to find the name of a film that has some similarities to this one. The similarity is that there is a navy trial/court martial about an incident on board a boat! I'd love to see it again but I can't remember what it's called!!

I'm pretty sure its a British film, and from the 1940s or 50s.
The plot concerns a young sailor who is very decent and likeable. He transfers from one ship to another. There, he is involved in an incident where someone dies, and there is a court-martial on board, where three senior officers meet below deck to decide if he should be hanged or not. They all like the young guy very much and have a lot of sympathy for him, but there is this very long trial scene where they realise they have to apply the law. I think one of them tries to resign from the trial, but the lead officer won't let him.
The other thing I remember is that the young sailor has a sort of gentle, ethereal quality, and there is a suggestion that he is a Christ-like figure. (This is never stated in the movie, but I remember it was in a lot of the commentary).

Anyway. I would love to see this again. I remember in particular the long trial scene, where the three officers were wrestling with this moral dilemma. That scene seemed to last a long time, but it was mesmerising - beautifully acted, and very moving.

Can anyone help??

_____________

"Maybe I should go alone"
- Quint, Jaws.

reply

The only film that comes to mind is 'Billy Budd' 1962???

reply


That's the one. :)
Thanks very much. Just enjoyed it again on youtube. I love that court martial scene. I'd forgotten Peter Ustinov was the main actor - he is excellent. As is Terence Stamp as BB.

Thanks again for your help. :)

_____________

"Maybe I should go alone"
- Quint, Jaws.

reply