MovieChat Forums > The Thing from Another World (1951) Discussion > American anti-intellectualism at its bes...

American anti-intellectualism at its best.


The foolish scientist seeks to communicate with what he doesn't understand, while everyone else tries to destroy it. The dumbest always know best.

The late naturalist Stephen Jay Gould, who was the Alexander Agassiz professor of Zoology at Harvard University, tore this film a new one in an essay once. He loathed the film and its message of vigilance vs reason. It glorifies fear, xenophobia, and irrationality.

This film was anti-communist propaganda at its worst. Fear the ways of the foreigner, yours is the true culture.. The foreigner seeks only to exploit and corrupt your people. It's a message that's been repeated many times in many cultures.

reply

As much as I respected Gould, I don't agree with him. I think this essay offers a more balanced and accurate look at the film's view of intellectualism: http://nukemars.com/?p=2434

reply

Pontificating is fun.

reply

Yeah, let's just ignore the fact that this creature was attempting to devour the members of the polar team (and possibly acting as a prelude to invasion), including Carrington, the archetype of the intellectual idiot, dedicated to the purity of his truth rather than basic survival. His mindset is responsible for the 20th century body-count of 100 million dead by various communist regimes.

reply

But it's nothing compared to the pseudo-intellectual claptrap contained in your post.

reply