MovieChat Forums > A Streetcar Named Desire (1951) Discussion > Is this the greatest film performance of...

Is this the greatest film performance of a lead actor AND actress?


Brando and Leigh are just wow.

----
"The early morning was the best time for seeing turtles." - A Dance With Dragons

reply

I am bumping my own post.

Come on guys I am curious if you also think this way or if there is another film with out there with such a strong leads?

----
Everyyyyyonnnnneeeeeee.

reply

Certainly in the discussion. A bit dated now, for sure.

I just watched it again Sunday. Brando's celebrated 'mumbling' has the surprisingly clear diction of the Actors Studio of the time.

reply

Its powerful and the performances Kazan got out of his actors in this and On The Waterfront shaped how roles where acted later on. Pacino and Keaton in GFII is huge, Hopkins and Foster in Silence of the Lambs would be other movies I'd put up for discussion.

reply

Keaton and Pacino? Honest? I thought she had very little to do (certainly not on the level of Leigh.) He's really good, but women in "Godfather" films just seem like used, put-upon stereotypes.

Hopkins and Foster are really great (as are Hopkins and Emma Thompson in their two outings.)

But the disintegration of these two characters from "Streetcar" into broken and damaged pieces is a showcase unlike any other.

reply

I personally did not like Marlon Brando in this.

My most favorites are Daniel Kash for Solo (2013/I) and Judy Garland for The Wizard of Oz (1939).

Volker Flenske: (While torturing David) I don't know why you're doing this to yourself!

reply

Paul Newman and Patricia Neal in HUD.

reply

Yes i think it is. However i also like Louise Fletcher and Jack Nicolson in " one flew over the cuckoos nest" and Anthony Hopkins and Jodie Foster in " Silence of the lambs"

reply

I prefer Taylor and Newman in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof

~Memories made in the coldest winter~

reply

Personally i prefer Burton and Taylor in Who's afraid of Virgina Woolf?
Although you could argue that its kinda similar, while here its more explosive while in woolfe, its an intensity that justs keeps building and becoming more personal and vicious.
That being said, i highly enjoyed the pairing with Leigh and Brando here as well!

reply