MovieChat Forums > An American in Paris (1951) Discussion > the top four movie musicals of all-time ...

the top four movie musicals of all-time / in no particular order

posted 16 years ago by oldsenior
32 replies | jump to latest

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The top four movie musicals of all-time / in no particular order are:

The Band Wagon
Singin' in the Rain
An American in Paris
Easter Parade

and tied for fifth place are:

Seven Brothers for Seven Brides
Meet Me in St Louis
Top Hat
Flying down to Rio
The Gay Divorcee
For Me and My Gal

and the ones for honorable mention are:

the 4 Mickey and Judy musicals

[–] kathleencurley1 16 years ago

My four would be:
There's no business like show business
Singin' in the Rain
Meet me in St. Louis
The Band Wagon

after that:
State Fair (1945)
Holiday Inn
The Wizard of Oz
High Society

[–] Shaqfan4eternity 15 years ago

This is so hard b/c i'm kinda new to musicals. I never really liked them at all, but since i;m getting into classic old films, a lot of them were musicals, so now i'm really loving musicals. So this is my four, but it will probably be tweaked since i still have lots of musicals 2 see.lol

1) Sound of Music-This will probably always be my #1 fav musical
2) Singing in the Rain-This movie was the first movie I ever saw with Gene Kelly in it, and now i'm in luv wit him 4ever.lol
3) An American in Paris- again, Gene Kelly, so HOTT!!! and a fabolous, amazing dancer.
4) Easter Parade- Luv Fred Astaire. Luv him in this film. Not 2 say that i'm happy that Gene Kelly broke his ankle and Astaire had 2 come out of retirement 2 play this part, but i'm glad he was in the movie.

coming in close
4) In The Good Old Summertime-such a sweet film. luv judy garland and van johnson in this.
5) Swing Time- the first film i saw with the pairing of Astaire/Rogers. Loved it!
6) Holiday Inn-that scene Astaire does with the firecrackers-genius

[–] aiwkid 16 years ago

My personal favorites:

1. The Wizard of Oz
2. Singin' in the Rain
3. Chicago
4. Grease

And just for the heck of it, I'll keep going:

5. Jesus Christ Superstar
6. Bedknobs and Broomsticks
7. Mary Poppins
8. Meet Me in St. Louis
9. Enchanted
10. Funny Girl
11. My Fair Lady
12. Hairspray
13. Easter Parade
14. The King and I
15. The Sound of Music

[–] scoobjr 15 years ago

Someone else that loves "Bedknobs and Broomsticks" !!! My favorite from when I was a kid.

[–] jaddeo 15 years ago

KAZABLAN
PAINT YOUR WAGON
SONG OF NORWAY
AT LONG LAST LOVE

[–] SeisCinemaSeis 16 years ago

1. The Umbrellas of Cherbourg
2. Singin' in the Rain
3. Lagaan
4. The Red Shoes

The fifth one would be either Chicago or My Fair Lady

[–] adamwarlock 9 years ago

The Red Shoes, while utterly brilliant, isn't really a musical in the sense of the other mentioned here. There's dancing but I don't recall any "break into song" moments.

Expansion to your ego.

[–] Doc_Ostrow 16 years ago

Just four? This is tough.

1) The Wizard of Oz
2) Singin' in the Rain
3) My Fair Lady
4) Oklahoma

Here are some others I like:

Enchanted
The Sound of Music
The Music Man
Carousel
The King and I
South Pacific
An American in Paris
Meet Me in St. Louis

I haven't seen The Umbrellas of Cherbourg for a long time but I have it on DVD, along with all the others on this list. I have Enchanted on Blu-ray.

Monsters from the Id

[–] WingHaz 15 years ago

1. Singing in the Rain
2. The Sound of Music
3. West Side Story
4. The Music Man

[–] louster6 15 years ago

FUNNY GIRL
Sound of music
sweeney todd
cannibal the musical

[–] raiderswin7799 15 years ago

I would have to go with

High Society
West Side Story
My Fair Lady
Bye Bye Birdie (who can resist Ann-Margaret?)

[–] Daisies5060 15 years ago

(in no particular order):

The Music Man
Singin' in the Rain
Calamity Jane
Funny Girl

"New York, this is your last chance."

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Huskie_Jon 15 years ago

An American in Paris
The Sound of Music
Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
The Blues Brothers
_______________
A dope trailer is no place for a kitty.

[–] morningsidemary 15 years ago

The Sound of Music
The King and I
West Side Story
The Wizard of Oz

Nobody ever lies about being lonely.

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] funkyfry 15 years ago

The Band Wagon
Gigi
An American in Paris
Cabin in the Sky

(can you guess who my favorite movie musical director is?)

Did I not love him, Cooch? MY OWN FLESH I DIDN'T LOVE BETTER!!! But he had to say 'Nooooooooo'

[–] 15 years ago

[deleted]

[–] musicrocks9 15 years ago

I can't do only four. and I definately can't do them in order.

Meet Me in St. Louis
Singing in the Rain
Hair
Funny Girl
Cover Girl
South Pacific
Sound of Music
An American in Paris
West Side Story
In the Good Old Summer Time
The Gay Divorce
Holiday Inn
Top Hat
Guys and Dolls

Pretty Much anything with Gene Kelly, Judy Garland, Fred Astaire and Ginger Rodgers, or Frank Sinatra.

"Twas I, but I used to beat her!" -Cover Girl 1944

[–] mcmxxxix 14 years ago

For me it would be:

West Side Story
The Sound of Music
Holiday Inn
Seven Brides for Seven Brothers

Close runners-up:
Oliver!
Gigi
White Christmas