MovieChat Forums > Joan of Arc (1948) Discussion > isnt the 146 minute version still cut?

isnt the 146 minute version still cut?


Im sure in the 146 min version that there are scenes missing. Isnt there a bit where she is outside the walls of Paris and tries to take it but fails, that leads to her capture?

Because it goes from a scene in the church where she is alone and saying that she must take up arms and go on, to a scene where she is on the back of a horse captured. What happened inbetween? Im sure its missing that bit there.

reply

You must have dreamed it maybe. For accuracy's sake I'll say that Joan actually was captured outside the walls of Compiègne, at the time under siege by english and burgundian forces.

On the other hand I've seen on the net some stills from scenes that weren't included on the released version.

One of those scenes was the one in which Joan tries to comfort a dying english soldier.

Another involves the reunion of Joan with her father, her brothers and her uncle Durand Laxard after the crowning of Charles VII in Rheims.

And yes, it seems that the capture of Joan at Compiègne was filmed but I'm not sure it wasn`t included on any of the commercially released versions of the film.

Here are the stills of the deleted scenes that I've seen so far:

http://www.stjoan-center.com/Ingrid/126.jpg

http://www.stjoan-center.com/Ingrid/127.jpg

http://www.stjoan-center.com/Ingrid/137.jpg

reply

You must have dreamed it maybe. For accuracy's sake I'll say that Joan actually was captured outside the walls of Compiègne, at the time under siege by english and burgundian forces.

On the other hand I've seen on the net some stills from scenes that weren't included on the released version.

One of those scenes was the one in which Joan tries to comfort a dying english soldier.

Another involves the reunion of Joan with her father, her brothers and her uncle Durand Laxard after the crowning of Charles VII in Rheims.

And yes, it seems that the capture of Joan at Compiègne was filmed but I'm not sure it wasn`t included on any of the commercially released versions of the film.

Here are the stills of the deleted scenes that I've seen so far:

http://www.stjoan-center.com/Ingrid/126.jpg

http://www.stjoan-center.com/Ingrid/127.jpg

http://www.stjoan-center.com/Ingrid/137.jpg

reply