MovieChat Forums > La Belle et la BĂȘte (1947) Discussion > Was it Greta Garbo or Marlene Dietrich w...

Was it Greta Garbo or Marlene Dietrich who said 'give me back my beast'?


I have little book on the making of this movie somewhere. It was either Greta Garbo or Marlene Deitrich who went to the premiere as the date of Cocteau and said this. (I think it was Marlene Dietrich. Greta Garbo was too shy, self-absorbed, and uninterested to have moved herself to leave her Hollywood home.)

reply

Robert Osbourne of TCM says Garbo.
Since he considers Cocteaus' Beast his favorite,I'd take his word.

reply

It was Dietrich.

reply

According to the trivia, it's Garbo.

If you're not taking any steps forward, you're not moving at all.

reply

It was Garbo. This was said last night by a professor of CUNY Graduate Center who specialises in Surrealist Literature when the film showed in City Cinematheque, CUNY TV. The films show on Saturday and Sunday at 9 pm EST and they repeat on Friday at midnight. Too bad I did not tape the 30 minutes discussion after the film! It was so interesting! This is also one of my favorite films.

The best in world cinema is showcased in City Cinematheque, CUNY TV's much-loved flagship weekend film series. Hosted by Professor Jerry Carlson and co-produced with the Department of Media and communication Arts of The City College, CUNY, each film is followed by lively discussion with scholars, film professionals and critics.


http://www.cuny.tv/show/citycinematheque/PR2000092

reply

Yes, it was Garbo.

Funny how the Garbo/Dietrich partisanship continues long after the deaths of both actresses.




"When logic and proportion have fallen sloppy dead ..."

reply

Greta Garbo was an introvert who preferred minimum social contacts and have real few friends, and to read books at home than partying and clubbing. It only take an extravert to bash Garbo over that and call her "too shy, self-absorbed, and uninterested".

I'm an introvert myself so I understand her.




====================================================
Perpetual coolness is the vampire's curse. - Mick St. John in Moonlight

reply