MovieChat Forums > Laura Discussion > Principles of police evidence violated i...

Principles of police evidence violated in this film


Just watched this film for the first time and, apart from how good it is, my initial reaction is, how could a police detective get away with that kind of behaviour and have any of his cases stand up in court? He brings suspects along when he questions other suspects, goes through the victim's apartment with the suspects, handles things and moves them around, eats and sleeps at the murder scene... And how about his questioning techniques at the station where he is the only level representative present? Did I miss anything?

reply

Did I miss anything?

You missed that he's drinking alcohol, in the morning -- while on duty. 

reply

There's no way around it; the plot is pretty flawed and full of leaps in logic.

But it's still a damn well made, fantastically directed movie. To quote the film trailer: "Laura is superb entertainment!"

~ I'm a 21st century man and I don't wanna be here.

reply

*Spoilers*


There's no way around it; the plot is pretty flawed and full of leaps in logic.

But it's still a damn well made, fantastically directed movie.


I did not find any flaws in the plot per se, just that it feels rather 'simple'/'weak' in comparison to other similar films of the era.

As far as his actions are concerned, one could surmise that Det. McPherson is not the upstanding officer that he once was, and has gotten himself emotionally 'tangled' in his case, as well as with the 'victim'.

reply

I couldn't help but remarking about this throughout the film. How is he getting away with all of this?? But you definitely let it slide because it's so damn entertaining.

reply

...drinks on the job, gets personally involved, insults the suspects....

Still, the film is extremely entertaining, stylish, well acted...it's one of my faves!

~~~~~
Jim Hutton (1934-79) & Ellery Queen 🎇

reply

Another oddity I noticed was that he doesn't carry a gun! When he removes his suit jacket in the apartment, no gun.At the end when Waldo fires at the officers he holds Laura but has no weapon. What sort of Detective goes about an investigation with no gun whatsoever?

reply

I didn't read any of the responses your post received so this may be a repeat.

Police procedure, within the "scope" of time is only recently "standardized." There is a stand-up comedian named John Mulaney with two specials on Netflix. In the one titled, "The Comeback Kid" he makes a joke about bank robbers taking credit for their bank heists and as long as they weren't there when the police arrived, they basically got away.

Now, understand that I am a bit biased. Almost all the men in my family have served in some branch of the military and went on to become cops. I know these people on a personal level and, quite frankly, while I love them as family members...I'm not sure I would feel confident they would not "skirt the rules" to get their targets.

On a personal note...I've been mugged, had my identity stolen twice and a couple of crimes against property I owned and the police NEVER did anything to catch any of the perpetrators. The only ones ever questioned were ones that I tracked down and whose information I gave to the police for the follow-up. None of them were ever prosecuted so I'm not convinced that everyone paying taxes actually get "service and protection" from the police.

-----
"Can we all just parachute down from Cloud Coo-coo Land?" Jimmy-Better Call Saul

reply

Okay, folks, please repeat after me: "It's only a movie". Thank you.

Fasten your seatbelts, it's going to be a bumpy night.

reply

...and I find that mysteries/thrillers are best when they are a bit far-fetched like this one. 

~~~~~
Jim Hutton (1934-79) & Ellery Queen = 

reply

Yeah, but:

1. It's "movie logic," or perhaps "poetic license,"

2. It was a different day. I'm sure those bright lights... and rubber hoses, etc... were in common use back then.

3. As a successful detective, injured on the job (the silver shin - shades of "King of the Hill's" dad!), he probably got a lot of slack from prosecutors.

4. Cops... and politicians... get away with much more these days!

reply

I thought it was odd that a police detective in a major city isn't issued a car, but has to take cabs everywhere.

reply