MovieChat Forums > Saboteur (1942) Discussion > 'Raiders of the Lost Ark' 39 Years Early...

'Raiders of the Lost Ark' 39 Years Early?


SPOILERS for "Saboteur"

George Lucas famously and conclusively said that his "Raiders of the Lost Ark" was inspired by the "Saturday afternoon serials" of his youth -- shorts that came before the main feature and ended in cliffhangers which were resolved the next weekend, with the next show, whereupon the story would move forward again, and end in ANOTHER cliffhanger. Til next week

The Indiana Jones movies smack of such quickie-adventures, while also having a wide-spread international flavor, as Indy travels the world from Nepal to Morocco to India to Germany and elsewhere.

All of this would militate AGAINST "Saboteur" having much influence on "Raiders of the Lost Ark," but there is still, in a certain sense, a feeling that "Saboteur" may have at least haunted George Lucas a BIT in his preparation of "Raiders" with director Spielberg and scenarist Lawrence Kasdan:

-- The hero wears a dark leather aviator jacket and tan slacks.

-- The villains are Nazis (albeit home-grown American Nazi traitor saboteurs.)

-- The story (like "Raiders") moves at a rapid pace from one episodic set-piece (the air hanger fire) to another (the horseback chase on Tobin's ranch) to another (Barry's leap from a high bridge into a roaring river) to another (the blind man's cabin) to another (Soda Springs) to another (the circus train), to another (the society ball, auction, and villains' trap) to another (the fight and blowing up of the Navy ship in Brooklyn harbor) to another (the chase and shootout during a movie at Radio City Music Hall) to another (the final cliffhanger on "Statue of Liberty.")

There's a bit of that episodic "Raiders" pace to "Saboteur", don't you think?

-- The hero romances a sassy dame who's sometimes his foe and eventually his (romantic) friend, and faces an elegant, arrogant villain.

-- And, finally, both "Saboteur" and "Raiders of the Lost Ark" are directed by men with fabulous visual sense and a taste for the continual rolling-out of cinematic ideas (a man who hangs by a thread from the Statue of Liberty; a traitorous monkey with a Nazi salute; a shooting in a movie theater that matches a shooting on the screen; a villain who burns the image of a vital medallian into his hand...)

Perhaps the more grandiose, star-studded Technicolor refinements of "North by Northwest" fed "Raiders" more than "Saboteur." "Raiders" stole one idea from "North by Northwest" directly: The cops trying to find Red Cap Cary Grant in a sea of men wearing Red Caps became Indy Jones trying to find Marion in a basket in a sea of baskets.

Bob Cummings' Barry Kane wasn't a brilliant archeologist with a bullwhip and a taste for adventure, but he WAS an all-American hero in bomber jacket and slacks, sent off on a fast-paced episodic adventure against Nazis which, at this great distance, looks more than a little like "Raiders of the Lost Ark" for the 40's.

reply

Hmmm...interesting comparison. Apropo of nothing ecarle, how exactly do you decide what movies to write these long (in a great way) posts on? Is it just whatever springs to mind? Do you take requests?

What's the spanish for drunken bum?

reply

Pretty much as springs to mind, often triggered by seeing the movie on TV recently.

I'm not against requests, but my "range" is fairly limited (a lot of Hitchcock, as many have noted.) I can't write as much on movies I'm not as familiar with.

Also, I try to stick to older movies because new movie boards are flooded with hundreds of posts and tend to skew younger than I am.

reply

I was (half) kidding about the requests, but did see I Confess last night, and was suprised you hadn't written one on that board. Have you seen it?

What's the spanish for drunken bum?

reply

I've seen "I Confess," I like "I Confess," and a few times at imdb, I've started a post on "I Confess" but been "distracted."

Soon...

I'd add: I did a whole other long post on "Saboteur" that got "bounced" by imdb just a few days ago. I guess they thought I'd said enough. If I can remember what I said, I'll re-post it.

Gotta get more respect for "Saboteur."

reply

what do you mean bounced?

reply

I sent it in, and it wasn't posted. This is my own terminology -- "bounced back" -- except I never saw it again. And I never kept a copy. Soon, I'll try to re-write it from memory and post it again.

reply

I didn't know they bounced blogs - I know they take them off if they are offensive.

reply

Well, maybe I just screwed up technically.

reply

bump.

reply


I will pick Saboteur anyday over Raiders of the Lost Ark. Saboteur was a low budget film with less known stars.

But they are still very interesting especially the villain played by Otto Kruger. As you know, Hitchcock thought he was miscast. But he is still one of the most memorable villains out of all Hitchcock films. I also love Vaughan Glaser who played the Blind Man. There are so many interesting "little" things in Saboteur that people don't notice. It also has a sample of James Bond like chords similar to the main fanfare.

Here is the link.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bs64RatBses

reply