Struck by lightning??


While "Sgt York" is just a so-so biopic, the bit where York gets hit by lightning and "see's the light" is a joke! York himself wanted Coop in it, fine! Was he hit by lightning in reality? - I doubt it! The hit by lightning bit is so contrived as to be laughable!
I've seen this film over a dozen times and have commented on it before.

Once York's in the service, the film improves considerably.
Coop's way too old for the part and recites his lines like a zombie.

reply

I read that the real story of York's conversion was by consistent witnessing over time by his (then) girlfriend, Gracie, which didn't make for "Hollywood drama."

reply

The screenwriters made the conversion extra dramatic because the real one occurred over time and was private. That would be virtually impossible to portray on screen in a short amount of time.
May I bone your kipper, Mademoiselle?

reply