MovieChat Forums > Rebecca (1940) Discussion > How do you guys think the film would've ...

How do you guys think the film would've played out if


The Second Mrs De Winter had been a lot more stronger from the get go or similar to Rebecca. Not cruel as she was, she'd still be her nice kind self but in terms of how she was percieved ergo: being considered as beautiful, etc but in a more pure, gracious way. Sort of like a person who is stunningly beautiful but they geninely don't know it or are quiet to regard compliments seriously .

So that Maxim fell for her because of her personality and because she was good version of what Rebecca would've been if she hadn't been such a cruel pyschopath- if the facade she put on for others was actually her real self.

Do you think it would affect the way the film ended ie: the reaction to the discovery of the body, Max confessiong, Miss Danvers burning down Manderley?

I think if the Second Mrs De Winter has been more like Rebecca I get the feeling Miss Danvers would have instead of trying to destroy her would have recognize the signs of Rebecca's personality within her and in her deranged mind thought she was Rebecca reincarnated/returned and would have become overly obsessed with her. So she does all the things such as comparing the way Rebecca wrote letters etc but she would do it in a way where she is trying to mould the Second Miss De Winter into Rebecca to replace her. Being nice but sort of forceful like the people who claim to be hardcore fans of a celebrity writing them letters, forcing their idealised image of them putting them on unrealistic pedastels etc. Emotionally manipulating her in buying the exact clothes Rebecca would've worn, getting her hair make up etc like Rebecca.

Also Favell would be trying to seduce the Second Miss De Winter but it fails.

Of course the more the Second Miss De Winter, as implied in the film, begins to look and act like Rebecca the more Maxim becomes distant and she can't understand why.

At first Mrs De Winter would view it as Mrs Danvers being nice and welcoming but then especially after seeing Rebecca's room she'd start to get a sense of how dangerous and obsessive Mrs Danvers truly is.

After the body is discovered I think it would trigger Mrs Danvers and Favell as in the book to start to realise Maxim's involvement in Rebecca's death and THAT would turn Mrs Danvers against them. And the house would still have burnt down.

How about you guys? If The Second Miss De Winter had been a bit less timid how would the film have played out

beauty freedom love truth

reply

If the second Mrs. de Winter would have been anything at all like Rebecca, there wouldn't have been a story to tell. Maxim specifically fell in love with her because she was nothing like Rebecca. She was the complete opposite. That is what Maxim wanted.

About Mrs. Danvers we can only speculate. If the second Mrs. de Winter had been more like Rebecca, I don't think she may have seen her as Rebecca reborn or reincarnated and transfer her obsession onto her. More the exact opposite. I think in Mrs. Danvers mind absolutely nobody could ever take the place of Rebecca and for any woman to even try she would see as a grave insult to Rebecca's memory.

Mrs. Danvers love/obsession/mania was always slightly unhinged and she would always have hated anyone who took Rebecca's place.

The house would definitively have been burnt down, no matter what.

Jessica Rabbit
"I'm not bad. I'm just drawn that way."

reply

I agree with you in that if the second Mrs. de Winter was more like Rebecca that Maxim wouldn't have gone after her. I think the big attraction to her was that she was the total opposite of Rebecca.

However, if the second Mrs. de Winter was stronger, she could/should have fired Mrs. Danvers. Mrs. Danvers still might have burnt the place down after being fired. So in reality we would not have the story line about Rebecca's death.

While watching it, I kept yelling at the TV and the second Mrs. de Winter to just fire that b&$@h Mrs. Danvers.

reply

"However, if the second Mrs. de Winter was stronger, she could/should have fired Mrs. Danvers."

Oh absolutely. Mrs. Danvers took way too many liberties considering she was a hired servant, albeit a very trusted one. But again, if she had been fired, we wouldn't have a story.

" Mrs. Danvers still might have burnt the place down after being fired."
We don't get around that one, do we?
Which is good, because it makes for a good story.

Jessica Rabbit
"I'm not bad. I'm just drawn that way."

reply

If she had been confident and assertive instead of an insecure door mat she would have fired Danvers's ass within the first week and told Maxim to stop treating her like a child. But that insecurity and poor treatment is what the book and movie are all about.

reply