Brother/Sister (?)
Many years ago a friend explained that WUTHERING HEIGHTS was actually about incest. Would Mr. Earnshaw have brought home some random street urchin? There were a lot of hungry children in British cities back in those days. Earnshaw brings home this boy and wants him to sleep in Hindley's room -- not in the servants' quarters.
More likely Heathcliff was the illegitimate child of Earnshaw and some woman (mistress?).
Do you think the filmmakers were aware of this in the casting? Casting Heathcliff and Cathy so they truly do look like brother and sister.
"The good end happily, the bad unhappily, that is why it is called Fiction."