MovieChat Forums > Dodge City (1939) Discussion > 'Goofs' people have no lives

'Goofs' people have no lives


Goof: "Lee Irving fires his six shooter eight times without reloading." OK, gee that was so important for me to know. But.....so what?

reply

That goof is almost as important as knowing that you disapprove of it.

reply

Lol, I don't even remember making that post. Obviously something I felt strong about at the time!

reply

If you knew your guns, you'd also know there was such a thing as a 9 shot revolver as well in those days. We had one left to us by our great-grandfather who rode the range in South Dakota.

It's smaller caliber, but if someone was counting shots, they got a surprise, and that's why he liked it.

-----
The Eyes of the City are Mine! Mother Pressman / Anguish (1987)

reply

Yep, The LeMat "grapeshot revolver fired 9 .40 caliber bullets, and one 20 bore charge of shot. Hell of a weapon.

"It ain't dying I'm talking about, it's LIVING!"
Captain Augustus McCrae

reply

Counting spent shots could have been very important to someone in a real situation.

reply

OK but in general goofs are small continuity errors.

You know the guys who made these movies never anticipated that we would be rewinding and freeze-framing and fast-forwarding to catch their inconsistencies.

Sometimes there are big errors but usually there aren't and I wish the error finders would confine themselves to pointing out the big ones.

reply

It just doesn't matter. Spotting goofs is fun. Relax.

reply