I saw this movie recently on TCM and don't have access to view it again, so could someone please explain exactly what Buck's role is in this story? I may be a bit dense but I found that I was rather befuddled throughout regarding this character.
Was Buck an old beau of Julie's, a family friend, or both? Did he love her? I realize that Julie was trying to use Buck in some way to get revenge on Preston or to make him jealous and it was eventually deemed a point of honour by Preston's brother, but what exactly was this fatal duel fought over?
Thanks very much in advance to anyone who responds!
Thanks, shadgrindk! I can see that the duel may have been Buck's way of showing his devotion to Julie, defending her honour somehow, though it was all rather unclear to me! I believe he attempted to talk Preston's brother out of the duel and when he couldn't, planned to merely nonfatally graze him with his shot.
I had the honor of watching this movie this morning. From my understanding, Buck was a very close family friend and an off-and-on beau of convenience for Julie. I think he cared for Julie but wasn't necessarily deeply in love with her. I also believe the duel was fought in defense of Amy rather than in defense of Julie... although Julie instigated the argument and lost control of the circumstances. In the end it was made clear that Buck knew Julie was using him but went through with the duel as he felt a gentleman should. I am certainly no expert; just a Southern gal that adores Bette Davis. ~K
And thanks to you, ktc22371! Being a Canadian with no expertise in such matters, I'll take the word of a Southern belle any day regarding a movie such as this!
I saw Buck as a symbol of the Old South bound by the traditions and prejudices of his priviledged society. He's a family friend, but there are seveal times where he let it be known that he does not want to be confined by one woman at this time. He may have been once a suitor for Julie's favor, as in the beginning where there is talk of his losing out to Press, but I think he is primarily a tool for Julie's foolishness. However, he stands as a example for Press's brother (as in the opening scene when the brother wants to second Buck in a duel).
Primarily, I think, he exists to contrast with Press who is going to marry Julie and take her North which no Southern gentleman could understand. It was like taking her to live with the savages in his estimation. Press, on the other hand, is much more open-minded (as when he talks about the growth and development in the North with the railroads and the need for the South to change with the times. He is still bound by the code of the South, but transgreses when he returns home with a wife from the North.
Buck gets caught up in a duel after he makes statements about Press and his betrayal of the South. The duel, I see, is an affirmation of the lack of flexibility in the code and of the backwardness of Southern life in a changing world. Although he tries to extricate himself by not shooting the brother, the brother, also bound strongly by the code and Press not there to advise him, ends up killing Buck. The killing of Buck provides Julie with the realization that her world has been selfish and frivolous, there are consequences for her bahavior, and begins her journey back towards redemption.
Thank you, ShivasGhost! You've given a wonderful explanation of it all, especially in pointing out Buck's traditional Southern attitude versus Preston's more open-minded one.
Buck was Julie's pawn, a cats-paw. Julie tried to demonstrate North/South differences, and the impracticality of Pres' and Amy's marriage, by playing on Buck's confederate jingoism, justifying inertia over progress; mechanized manufacture over slave labour, and Buck tries to goad Pres by accusing him of denying his heritage.
After Pres leaves, Buck redoubles his efforts toward the sole remaining Northern sympathizer, Amy, and Pres' brother calls him on it.
Buck has no real ill-will toward either Pres or Amy, insofar as he confesses to Pres' brother that he knew what Julie was doing, all along.
Many anti-fur protests, few anti-leather. Seniors & models must be easier to bully than bikers.