MovieChat Forums > Mad Love (1935) Discussion > Good and creepy film

Good and creepy film


Peter Lorre .... Doctor Gogol
Frances Drake .... Yvonne Orlac
Colin Clive .... Stephen Orlac
Ted Healy .... Reagan, the American Reporter
Sara Haden .... Marie, Yvonne's Maid
Edward Brophy .... Rollo the Knife Thrower

It had been four years since Lorre's disturbing and controversial film "M" had debuted and only one year since Alfred Hitchcock's first making of The Man Who Knew Too Much starring Lorre. This film places Lorre in another somewhat disturbing role about a surgeon, Doctor Gogol played by Lorre, who is obsessively in love with a beautiful actress, Yvonne Orlac played by Frances Drake. Francis Drake's character is married to a traveling pianist, played by Colin Clive of Dr. Frankenstein fame.

Stephen Orlac happens to be on a train that a prisoner, played by Edward Brophy as the murderer Rollo the knife thrower, is being transported to his scheduled execution. While in transport the train wrecks and Orlac's hands are both severely injured.

Yvonne Orlac desperate to save her husbands hands takes him to the neurosurgeon Dr. Gogol. Gogol suggests amputation but Yvonne insists there must be something more he can do. Gogol seems to enjoy attending executions and in a moment of insight he devises a way to attach the hands of the now deceased Rollo in place of Orlac's real hands. Through therapy he is able to gain use of the hands but the hands have a mind and will of their own...those of their previous owner. They like to throw knives! :o

This film is really well done and I would consider it to be a cult classic. The subject is creepy and Lorre adds depth and dimension to Doctor Gogol and his obsessive love for Mrs. Orlac that eventually leads him into trouble.

I give this 4 1/2 out of 5 stars.

Have you seen this film? What are your thoughts about it?

Kevin
Check out http://www.goldenageofhollywood.com

reply

[deleted]

Terrific film, way ahead of its time. A much more effective thriller than most of the effects-laden junk being produced today.

I wonder: How did audiences react to "The Mask" when it was released in 1935? I'd imagine it could very well have induced dizziness and fainting, and probably more than a few audience members had to flee the theater.

reply

I loved it. By reading the premise, you'd expect this to be a "so bad it's good" type of movie, but it actually was made with a lot of loving care. Dr. Gogol is not a one-dimentional character, but someone you actually feel sorry for. He's a good man, but he's a recluse who's developed a few unwholesome habits to fill the void. In other words, his social skills could be better. :) His obsession with both death and Madam Orlac may be due to both being profoundly shy as well as the quirkiness of extreme genius. Whatever the case, you sense that Dr. Gogol is compassionate and, at least initially, sincere. The moments when he's confronted with unrequited love are heartbreaking. It's because you actually like the man that you get drawn into the story, and hope that somehow things will resolve peacefully. But hey...we're talking Peter Lorre here. The man doesn't play characters who get a break. :) Very good movie that you can watch over and over again. And isn't it strange to see Ted Healy without his Stooges??

reply

nice review





When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

Great review, what a fantastic film. I'm a little mad at myself for not seeing it years ago.

9/10

reply

Watched this for the first time in about 20 years last night (part of the Horror Legends box set)just wonderful! Lorre does 'creepy weirdo' with such conviction. He looks totally crushed when Yvonne says she's giving up the theatre to be with her husband, though..those eyes. Brilliant.

reply

Thanks to TCM on demand, just saw this movie. Great stuff. Love a bald Lorre. Very creepy. Gogol likes watching beheadings, he looks like he might be pleasuring himself in his little box seat as Yvonne is being "tortured" on stage...a little BDSM there. Buys the wax figure of her for his bedroom, where he can play his organ for her...perhaps both of his organs.

I don't think I'm reading too much into it. Genuinely creepy film. Loved it.

End of the world? So what.

reply

"...both of his organs..." I loved your reference!😁 And the movie is really incredible!

reply

Lol re: organs. And perhaps he takes the executed mans head cause that's the only "head" he can get. Eh, a stretch...

reply

[deleted]

We grew up on this movie in Los Angeles. It was on often on Saturday afternoon Chiller or Thriller horror movie festivals. This was our favorite with anything Boris Karloff or Bela Lugosi. I had not seen it in decades, but had not forgotten it. I couldn't remember this name, and had forgotten how awfully the actress treated Dr. Gogol.

reply

Watched it today and I really liked it

reply