MovieChat Forums > Of Human Bondage (1934) Discussion > The Mildred / Bette Davis Character

The Mildred / Bette Davis Character


Although I really enjoyed this film, I did not enjoy certain aspects of Bette Davis' character and/or performance and/or the way in which she was directed and/or the way in which the script was written for her. (As you can see, I'm a little confused about who to blame it on.) In any case, her mannerisms and speaking style were so over-the-top weird in some of the scenes that she seemed almost mentally ill--or at least having more than her share of psychiatric disorders. Frankly, this didn't work for me.

If Mildred is supposed to be cold-blooded, predatory, and cruel, then it ruins everything to have her also appear to be so strangely mentally disturbed. You see, to be cold-blooded, predatory, and cruel requires mental capacity--mental capacity that is not usually possessed by someone whose speech and mannerisms are so far outside the range of normal behavior.

For all I know, Bette Davis' performance was perfect and I should blame what I don't like on the director and/or the script writer. (You tell me.) Despite my complaints, I think it's a great film. I particularly enjoyed the restaurant scene in which each man was competing for Bette Davis' attention.

reply

I have a feeling the PTB hadn't a clue what to do with the Mildred character. I never read the book, which I have to do. But it looks like she was suppose to be a prostitute. One of his frineds tells that she was more or less asking for money and looking at her it wouldn't take long to see what she will do next. Plus silent films weren't to far behind and I think that over acting was still the way to go. I also thought it was funny that Ms Davis would slip in and out of Midreds english accent. In old movies when women are very independent and I am not sure if she was such a bad person or he was just real dumb. She has to crazy but child like spoil brat crazy. Back to him... he knew she liked to go out with men a lot. He knew that the first second he saw her. She laid it out there for him to see too. He would day dream about her like she was some type of angel. But Mildred never said she was . She had a baby out of wedlock, but the married man is worse then she was. He offers no support in matter of fact he laughs it off when he is asked what he is going to do about the baby. But he is portrayed in the movie as some happy go lucky character. She is the crazy villian. I agree she does act like she is a nut but I think it was intentional because women like her in movies have to be crazy and they have to be punished because she was mercenary. I still don't believe she was a bad person though. He in the other case I think is the one with the real mental defect, which was symbolized by the club foot. We have a future doctor who basically likes to get dogged. It is not like he doesn't have friends and other girlfriends. So both of them were crazy but he was crazier then she

reply

[deleted]

I am just talking about the movie. If we just talk about the movie alone IMO he was sexually obesed. The other women in the movie treated him very nice, but he dogged them. Now this is just the movie. The book is another story. Please don't get me started on Mr Philip Carey

The movie leaves out most of the beginning of the book. In the book he doesn't seem so nice either. His mother dies and his father is already dead. They send him to a uncle and his wife is a vicar. They have no children but they try to treat Philip well. All he has to say is nasty things about the wife, how she looks etc.
They send him to school and he is teased but soon that is over with. And he gets honors for being a good student. He does make a good friend who he treats with contempt he has nothing good to say about anyone. He gets mad because the friend finds another friend. When this friend tries to befriend him again he turns away from him. Then they let him leave the school because he is not happy and he works at a accountant. He has nothing but bad things to say about his boss and co workers. One who was nice enough to have him go with them to Paris where he tries to show him a good time.
But before that he moves to Germany and he has nasty things to say about the people in the boarding house but befriends one man, who he also had nasty things to say about before he knew him. But that man goes to Paris. All along no one is really bothered by his foot but him. Then he goes along with the gossipers who are against the young girl and her relationship with the chinese man, making fun of him too. Then he goes back to the vicar and demands to go to Paris. His Aunt gives him the money she has left in her account so he will not pawn his dead fathers stuff. Then and only then does he realize she loves him. He even says earlier that she loves him because he made her suffer, which was wrong. But wait a minute we must not forget how he treats Miss Wilkenson. He obviously slept with her and then talks about how ugly she looks. She is in love with him and all he does is ignore her. She writes him in Paris and he doesn't even open her letters. Then has nothing but contempt for Miss Price because she is strong willed, but she is also very poor and he makes comments about her poverty.
Oh his foot is so bad he turns out to be a such a good tennis player that he makes a nasty comment about the other players while he is trying to talk to the young girls that visits the vicar. This man is a contemptable gnome. And since I read the book I think even then before there is something wrong with him. And it has nothing to do with his foot.
You see I can't get past the way he treated Miss Wilkenson. She let him be himself and she treated him nice. She loved him. And yes he has the right to reject her. But the way he acted was reprehensible. So when Mildred comes along she kind of treats him the way he treated Miss Wilkerson. I do not think it has anything to do with her letting him be himself. Because she didn't like him as himself. The other women did though.
I think they should remake the movie and put some of the beginning of the book in it. There are some very interesting characters like his friends in Paris, Miss Wilkenson, Mis Price, and his Aunt and Uncle. His stay in Germany. Some of his teachers. They really did not do the book any justice.

reply

[deleted]

I was trying to point out why I feel he was not such a nice guy. Perhaps by your nasty uncalled for response I can see why you would relate and defend such a character. I do not need you to advise me to look at a book in a different way because it suits the way you feel about it. And he has more then just a cynical way of outlook on life. He is down right nasty. Every one in his child hood treated him nice for the most part and indulged him. His mother dying is no excuse for him acting like a jerk. It was semi autobiographical. But actually Philip was a combination of characters Maugham knew.

reply

[deleted]

Apology accepted. Ok here goes Norah was very nice and he was able to act the way he wanted around her. She was supportive about his exams, knew he needed a rest after them. Listened to him and she also slept with him too. She was a good friend and lover. Mildred was very nasty, he was even afraid to talk to her because of him being afraid that she would rebuff him. The man could not even pass his exams, his whole life stopped. If anything he could not be himself around her at all. I want to say I have never heard of such a obsession. He even admits that he thought of her sexually too.. He was thinkig of making her drunk but she wasn't a drinker. Then he askes her to go to Paris even though he could not even afford it. Then he asks to marry her and he didn't care he didn't have to money to do and didn't care of the rebuff he would get in society for marrying a waitress. He follows her all over the place, he tells her that he loves her and she lets him know she did not have those feelings for him. Then he capitualates when she decides she wants to date other people. He wanted her so much she could basically treat him like a dog and he accepted it. This is funny because he also calls her vulger and she looked ill with a green tint to her skin and is flat chested. I have to think he doesn't belieeve he deserves better. But then why does he rebuff the women who do care for him? There were not so called "respectable" either. He talked badly about Fanny too, but she loved him and he rejected her. So why is he so taken with Mildred? Is it because of the guilt of Fanny commiting suicide. It can't be that. I have to think he was just obssessed.

One thing the movie kind of was true to the Mildred character. Other then she was a little more vulger in the movie. In the book she acted more like a snob wannabe. I had the idea she would pick up a bottle of Gin and drink in the movie and she was not ill...with a green tint, hilarious.

I am sticking to my guns about Philip I think he is a nasty person too. Not in the way Mildred is, but he never has too much good to say about people either but he is not so outward about it...also because he considers himself a "gentleman". He befriends a person in school and he calls him dumb. And even makes another comment about it when the friend passes his exams and he didn't. Heywood comes back to town and he is nasty about him too. Now this is a guy who acted like a fool just a few months earlier he has a lot of nerve talking about anyone. It is pointed out numerous times in the book that he makes more of his club foot then anyone else. Even Mildred said that. In the days he lived it was not unusual to had been orphaned, but at least he had family to raise him. It was not unusual to have some type of affliction. So what was his problem? Other then him imagining himself as a victim and being a cad.

reply

[deleted]

The moment that was odd to me was when Davis is telling Howard off and she keeps looking at the floor. It almost looks like she's reading her lines off the floor (although she delivers them well). Odd.

reply

[deleted]

I agree completely. I really do think Katherine Hepburn (who was originally considered for the role) would have fitted it more comfortably. I just felt that Davis tried too hard and wasn't believable in the role.

reply

[deleted]

A funny bit is where Bette/Mildred is in the hospital and she just had the baby and she says "Funny little looking thing isnt it? Cant believe its mine" that made me laugh lol :P

reply

[deleted]

Why?

suzycreamcheese RIP Heath Ledger 1979-2008

reply

I really do think Katherine Hepburn (who was originally considered for the role) would have fitted it more comfortably.


Gad! What a thought. With Katherine Hepburn. And. Her. Stilted. And. Robotic. Way. Of. Delivering. Lines.

I can't think of anyone less suited to the role of Mildred...ok maybe Jimmy Durante, but even then...


So put some spice in my sauce, honey in my tea, an ace up my sleeve and a slinkyplanb

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]