However, Hays (who was Presbyterian) was only a tool, in both meanings of the word. The aforementioned child molesters would have found someone else, if not him, to do their bidding.
Well exactly.
It's hard to believe now, but back in the 20s and 30s, the motion picture industry faced a boycott by religious and social organizations (and the possibility of legislation) unless they "cleaned up their act." Hence the Hays Code. The Code was their attempt at self-censorship before anyone else could get jump in and start doing it for them.
Of course, enacting a code and
enforcing that code are two different things. And it was only in 1934 that the Hays Code had actual teeth. Until then, moviegoers were treated to some real gems.
Freaks (1932) comes to mind, as does
Miracle Woman (1931).
Also, just because the Hays Code was enforced didn't mean the censors couldn't be fooled. I'm re-reading the book
The Monster Show, where it talks about James Whale and his fight with the Hays Code people. The original
Frankenstein was, of course, pre-code (1931). But
Bride was made in 1935 and the atmosphere four years later (and after many other horror films tried to copy the success of
Frankenstein) was quite different.
It makes you laugh to read about it: he played them like a piano. Whale understood
exactly how those people worked. And he went out of his way to be charming, solicitous, and "easy to work with." Of course, he knew what he was after and made exactly the kind of picture
he wanted to make. And the end result has some
really eye-popping "hidden" meanings that it doesn't take long to pick up on.
Something else to consider: just because your film was (finally) approved by the Production Code Administration (i.e. the enforcement arm of the Code) didn't necessarily mean that your troubles were over. Apparently, there were state and local censorship boards that had to be appeased as well. All meeting the Hays Code did was allow you movie to be
released on the Hollywood end. If the local censorship boards didn't like what you had to offer, your picture might not be shown unless you were willing to make the cuts (edits) that they deemed necessary to preserve the "moral integrity" of the people they purported to represent.
I've always wanted a job with, say, the National Legion of Decency, where I would do nothing but screen "morally offensive" movies for myself all day long in order to "make sure" that they were unfit for other people to see. :)
reply
share