MovieChat Forums > Un chien andalou (1929) Discussion > Top 10 most influential films

Top 10 most influential films


My teachers say that this film is one of the most influential films ever. I could see why they say that, after looking on line I couldn't find a definitive top 10 most influential film list so I was wondering what people thought. I did find Roger Ebert's top ten list and I was really appalled becasue it included The Blair Witch Project, here is the link.

http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/19991230/COMMENTARY/212010334

Anyway what are the top ten most influential films???

reply

Here's Ebert's comment on Blair Witch:

Important not for its entertainment value, which was considerable, but for what it represented in technical terms. Released last summer, it was the first indie blockbuster, a film made for about $24,000 and shot entirely on inexpensive hand-held cameras (one film, one video), which grossed more than $150 million. The message was inescapable: In the next century, technology will place the capacity for feature filmmaking into the hands of anyone who is sufficiently motivated, and audiences will not demand traditional "production values" before parting with their money.

I think he has a point here; although, I'm not certain that I'd include the film in my list. I don't know what films would be on my list. Ebert's list is remarkably US-centric. The only exception is "Potemkin", which I think belongs on the list. Where is the French New Wave or Ingmar Bergman? I think film noir belongs on there somewhere.

My advice is to look for movies considered "influential", and see them for yourself. Be sure to put them in historical and artistic context.

But here's one I think I'd have to put in my list: "Shoot the Piano Player".

reply

ALL lists should be “US-centric.” We are the hub of the fucking world.

reply

I would completely agree with every movie Roger Ebert's list, but here are a few that come close:

Thomas Edison shorts - first images captured on film
A Trip to the Moon - first narrative
Un Chien Andalou - first experimental
Gone With the Wind - highest grossing movie (adjusted for inflation)
Sunset Blvd. - brave criticism of Hollywood
Bicycle Thief - did not have the traditional Hollywood ending and influenced many 70's directors
Breathless - was more about emotions than narrative and had new editing techniques
Jaws - first summer Blockbuster

reply

My list would be more or less the following:

un chien andalou
rashomon
jurassic park
russian ark
wild strawberries
man with a movie camera
koyaanisqatsi
apocalypse now
2001:ASO
blair witch project
ayneh (powerful not influential though)
salo

reply

my top 25 list of the most influential films would include (Besides Buñuel's "Un chien andalou"):

Persona by Ingmar Bergman
Rashomon by Akira Kurosawa
Three Colors by Krzysztof Kieslowski
Nosferatu by F.W. Murnau
2001: A Space Odyssey by Stanley Kubrick
Metropolis by Fritz Lang
Modern Times by Charlie Chaplin
8 1/2 by Federico Fellini
Los olvidados by Luis Buñuel
Battleship Potemkin by Sergei Eisenstein

The Godfather by Francis Ford Coppola
Fitzcarraldo by Werner Herzog
Alphaville by Jean-Luc Godard
Day for Night by François Truffaut
Vertigo by Alfred Hitchcock
Lawrence of Arabia by David Lean
Ivan's Childhood by Andrei Tarkovsky
Taxi Driver by Martin Scorsese
Princess Mononoke by Hayao Miyazaki
Videodrome by David Cronenberg
The Bicycle Thief by Vittorio De Sica
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly by Sergio Leone
El Topo by Alejandro Jodorowsky
The Gospel According to St. Matthew by Pier Paolo Pasolini
and Star Wars by George Lucas (inevitable even if you don't like it)

reply

Why Modern Times?...It was one of the final silent movies...

reply

Why Modern Times??? The fact of being one of the last silent movies as you pointed out, doesn't matter at all. The reason why I picked it, is because it mixes comedia with a strong criticism towards the savage capitalism and dehumanized world where we live. Because 70 years later is still "Fresh and Modern".

How many movies (comedies or not) after "Modern Times" have achieved that? Many have tried but just a few have been "almost" as succesful as MT. Not agree? Can you list them?
Probably you are going to mention the "Qatsi" trilogy, then have in mind that Chaplin did it (In a completely different way, though) almost 50 years before.


BTW Now that you are questioning my picks: Why you've mentioned "Russian Ark"? I suppose because it was shot in one take with a steadicam? Was because of that?

Ok that's ORIGINAL, but INFLUENTIAL? I don't think so. I haven't seen any movie that have followed the path of RA. Ok maybe is because the movie is relatively new, Anyway I don't think filmmakers are gona follow the same path than the director of Russian Ark.

If so I'd have added "AKA" by Duncan Roy a movie that splits horizontallly the screen with three images: "A Tryptich". Each one telling the same story from a different perspective or telling the story in a different time frame.

Sth similar to Mike Figgis' "Timecode" but even more extreme, more ORIGINAL. But I haven't added it to my list because I don't think it will influence other filmmakers enough to make their movies as "tryptichs" with an aspect ratio close to 4.00:1.

BTW why Jurassic Park? and why not TRON? the latter predates JP for a decade in the using of CGI effects as a main resource to tell a story.

I'd continue but I'll stop here.

reply

Whoa... you know your cinema, agreed. I just wanted to know your reason for putting MT, thats all. Chaplin is my favorite comedian too, BTW.

reply

Oh, Equinoccio, get over yourself. I agree with much of what you say, especially about Tron. But give it a rest. Everyone has an opionion, no matter how stupid. You're no different. Grow stronger skin.
Wes

reply

Oh, thank you for mentioning Personna and the Gospel According to St. Mathew. No one remembers these. I saw The Gospel on my 18th birthday after signing up for the draft for Vietnam. I needed someting spiritual, ya know? And Personna I have never understood but cherished. Very good list. Thanks. Wes

reply

For a much agreed upon top 10 list check the Sight and Sound Poll that comes out every 10 years starting in 1952, with the last one occurring in 2002.

www.bfi.org.uk/sightandsound/topten/history/

reply

[deleted]

seven samurai
Un chien andalou
the great train robbery
citizen kane
a trip to the moon
battleship potemkin
metropolis
Nanook of the North
vertigo
2001 a space odyssey
The birth of a nation(hate me for it but it brought about classical cinema)

But i think a lot of these can easily be switched out with others but i would have to say battleship potemkin needs to be in there for sure.

sorry my mind tends to wander in moments of silence

reply

In no particular order I would list the 10 most influencial as:

Night of the Living Dead
Easy Rider
Citizen Kane
Metropolis
City Lights
Un chien andalou
Jaws
Pulp Fiction
Psycho
Seven Samurai


In the event of a remake please consider the original to be my intended choice.


Honarable mentions (almost make my list):
8'1/2
Stagecoach
F for Fake
Symbiopsychotaxiplasm: Take One
Shane
Clerks
Halloween
Star Wars
The Blair Witch Project
This is Spinal Tap

reply

fight club
the matrix
the dark knight
artificial intelligence
into the wild
like stars on earth
3 idiots

reply

Citizen Kane
Birth of a Nation
Breathless
Man with a movie camera
Sunrise
2001 : A space odyssey
The Bicycle thief
Psycho
The 400 blows
Potemkin


Later that day, after tea... I died, suddenly.

reply

10. Cabinet of Dr Caligari

9. Man With A Movie Camera

8. The Seventh Seal

7. La Dolce Vita

6. Akira

5. Chinatown

4. Taxi Driver

3. The Shawshank Redemption

2. Zach Braff

1. Batman Begins

reply