MovieChat Forums > Richard Spencer Discussion > So he wants a homeland for white people....

So he wants a homeland for white people. What's wrong with that ?


Considering that white people are in the process of becoming minorities in their own countries ( and we all know how that worked out for the Jews and considering the hatred that is being directed at whites ) what is wrong with Richard Spencer talking about homelands for white people ? It seems sensible and reasonable to me.


reply

He should go back to his homeland then.

reply

Okay I didn't know anything about this guy and reading his wiki page it seems he is a Neo Nazi clown. Having said that I still think he is right about white homelands.

Anyway to reply to your point he is a white person born in America and to my mind that makes America his homeland.


reply

I don't know much about Spencer, but I do know you can't trust Wikipedia when it comes to anyone who's even slightly right wing.

reply

Don't trust Wikipedia when it comes to anything about politics. It's just a left wing echo chamber. Article about him is just a smear.

reply

By your same logic, to native Americans born in the USA, America is also their homeland... and if you read a little bit of history, they were here first. How does this scenario play out in your mind?

reply

England doesn't want his Nazi ass and White people don't deserve their own "homeland" when you look at what Whites have done to the planet.

reply

And what have whites "done to the planet" ?

reply

Have you been living under a rock all your life? They've been the main contributors to the planet's destruction and its wildlife. Whites have also systematically enslaved and committed genocide against every other group on the planet. Trying to defend that is like giving someone like Ted Bundy a pass. Again, serial killers........ almost all WHITE.

reply

Have you been living under a rock all your life?


And another bottom feeding sock puppet troll announces itself.

reply

So you put the (albeit ignorant and racist) question out to the internet world, and then you call out names to those who dare respond in a contrary opinion...?

reply

Did your parents send you to Commie Camp? (it's a real thing)

reply

Socialists, not whites!

reply

Then stop using white inventions. Have fun eating rats in your makeshift shanty.

reply

What do you men by "white inventions"?

reply

Like pretty much everything you use.

reply

The wheel wasn't invented by whites. White people would probably have died out if it weren't for the invention of the wheel.

"Like pretty much everything you use."

Wrong. They normally stole ideas from non-whites.

reply

WUM

reply

You're defending a neo-Nazi. Do you strongly identify with his ideology?

reply

Absolutely nothing. The people who oppose this are hypocrites. Exclusion is oppression only when Whites do it. When all others do it it's totally OK.

reply

"we all know how that worked out for the Jews"

The Holocaust!

Spencer's ideas are similar to Hitler's early ones before his Final Solution.

reply

Racist slut comes alive.

reply

Yeah, Spencer is a racist slut. Anti-Semite, too.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1o6-bi3jlxk

reply

You're witnessing the results of decades of work by far left radicals (who now represent the mainstream). I don't even care about white people having a homeland for themselves. I'm just not dumb enough to ignore the parallels between classical anti-Semitism and the manufactured rage against white people.

reply

Absolutely nothing. Whites deserve their own Homeland(s).

reply

I support the idea of all white supremacists moving to a distant island.

reply

The thing is that there are no leftists that are actually opposed to a white ethnostate on principle

What American leftists ARE opposed to is turning the United States into a white ethnostate. That would require expelling all non-whites from the country, and the policies necessary to make this happen would need to be extremely authoritarian. There were non-whites living in the United States since its inception, modern white nationalists try to re-write history and make it seem like a white ethnostate would be a return to something that never actually existed in this country. What DID exist were laws that were discriminatory against non-whites, but not laws that prevented non-whites from living in the country

If people who believe in a white ethnostate want to occupy a piece of uninhabited land and create their own sovereign white nation, I don't think anyone would try to stop them. But what white supremacists like Spencer REALLY want is to take control of a current first-world Western nation and re-write its laws to remove all non-whites

In theory there may be nothing racist about the idea of an exclusively all-white nation, but in order to create it in practice in the way that the Spencers of the world want it it would absolutely require policies that are, in effect, the same as those used in Nazi Germany to expel all Jews from the country. That is why many people use the blanket term "Nazi" to describe people like Spencer. It isn't because they're stupid or brainwashed and are misunderstanding their message, it's because if you actually get into the nitty gritty about how these ideas would come into effect you see that it would essentially be Nazism all over again

reply

As long as he takes all the bigots and morons like you with him, then I'm all for him creating his own country.

reply