MovieChat Forums > Taylor Swift Discussion > What's so special about her?

What's so special about her?


I don't get the appeal.

reply

This is actually a great question.

What sets her apart from other pop singers: she’s popular.

Why is she popular?
Because there’s nothing else available. Pop music is gone and it left a vacuum so we get 1 new artist every few years. Right now is TS’s time.

In time she won’t be remembered for anything other than how popular she was.

There is nothing different, or innovative, or catchy, about her music. If someone said it was AI generated would you really argue with them? It’s completely vanilla and unmemorable. It’s a saltine cracker without the salt.

None of it will be talked about in 50 years just Like 99% of motion pictures released after 2005.

reply

Gd5150, I agree. Taylor Swift will never be on the same level as the Beatles, Elvis Presley, Michael Jackson, and Madonna.

reply

Those artists couldn't exist now as they did then. They couldn't have the same success.

The "legendary bands" you refer to produced music in a time when popular music in the west was in a state of development. People in the 60's and 70's did not have many options available to them. Everyone mostly huddled around a radio and listened to what was played to them by record labels. People's tastes were homogenised in a way that they simply aren't now. This gave promoted bands major cultural capital, power and lasting resonance in a way that is impossible now.

If you wanted to get into music exploration yourself, you had to have money and connections and a local record store to do so. That's all gone now. The internet blew the gates wide open and allowed for counter-culture (in music) to take a major seat at the table. This led to an explosion of music variety as geography became no boundary and bands and projects, no matter where they were could just share their music anywhere.

What chance would you have given an Estonian Shoegaze band in the 1980's? Or a Filipino Post-Hardcore project then? The concept of an era being defined by a dozen "legendary" (and apparently exclusively rock artists ) bands is simply antiquated and regressive. People are far more eclectic and varied in their listening interests now, and what we have is a much larger pool of respected artists and bands within a large pool of subcultures and subgenres.

reply

>None of it will be talked about in 50 years just Like 99% of motion pictures released after 2005.

Do you think stuff that doesn't remain spoken about 50 years later inherently sucks?

reply

Nothing

reply

She's got talent and style, but that's not uncommon in the music field. She's just one of the ones that struck a chord with a lot of people, much like Elvis, The Beatles, Michael Jackson, Merle Haggard, and Garth Brooks in their own times. You could say she's in good company. I admit I do like a few of her songs, and I'm 54.

reply

EXACTLY! I can't name one song she sings. My coworkers played one of her "best" songs for me and it was not good at all...I had to ask what was so great about this. I highly doubt she has any GROWN ADULT fans.

reply

I don't know her music but I think she is gorgeous.

reply