MovieChat Forums > M. Night Shyamalan Discussion > An Indian man who makes films EXCLUSIVEL...

An Indian man who makes films EXCLUSIVELY starring white people


That's always seemed so odd to me. He only writes white characters. Even with Airbender, he cast an all white cast. But FAR beyond that film... It's very fascinating to me.

A quick search shows that M Night was born in India (and immediately moved to America) and was raised Hindu. But in America as a kid he attended a private catholic school. Know what his first film was about? A white catholic schoolboy. He has never made a film about people of his own ethnicity. And considering he's nearly 50 years old and has been directing for two decades, I doubt he ever will. As a minority, the first thought that came to me... can he even relate to Indian people? Even his name has been white washed. He uses only his first initial which obscures his very ethnic first name and added "Night" to his pseudonym, leaving only his last name as any trace of having Indian origin.

It's clear that he's accustomed to a mostly white point of view. He won't make films starring people of his own ethnicity, he won't even make films of characters with the same religion as him... yet he'll make a film about white Catholics. It feels like he's suppressed his own identity to fit in. So I was most surprised to learn that he is, in fact, married to an Indian woman. I definitely expected him to have a white wife.

__
Long ago men competed on a show to date a woman who competed on a show to date Flava Flav.

reply

This message has been deleted by the poster

reply

His first film, Praying with Anger, limited release 1992. Filmed in India with an entirely Indian cast.

Since then Unbreakable has two black actors in lead roles, Lady in the Water is full of people from a different ethnicity (black, Asian, Latino, white), After Earth focuses exclusively on a black family, The Sixth Sense, Signs and The Visit have black or Asian actors in the cast.

If he's more comfortable around white suburbia then fair enough, but his movies are more culturally diverse than many other directors of the same generation. I don't think he needs to make Indian movies anymore than James Wan should make Malaysian movies or that Steve McQueen has to make movies about Black British people.

reply

You're like that person who had a fit about them hiring a 'white guy' to play Akmenrah in Night at the Museum

reply

Not everyone is going to fit into your stereotypical boxes.

Is there something wrong with his work, or the way he lives his life? Does it upset you?

reply

Wait, Dev Patel, Cliff Curtis, and Shaun Toub are white? Didn't know.

reply

And bet you didn't know Anya Taylor-Joy is Argentine-British.

reply

Rami Malek is of Egyptian descent.

reply

Well, they all have at least one indian guy in them, namely Shyamalan himself, so...

reply