The reluctant Pop Star
I like many of Phil's songs and a lot of his works with Genesis, but does anyone else agree that Phil has projected this strange aloof persona where it sometimes looks like he'd rather be somewhere else?
Maybe that was part of his appeal since he couldn't compete with contemporary 80s and 90s heartthrobs like George Michael, Prince, Sting, and Bruce Springsteen to name a few. Just make music that appeals to a majority and don't sweat the visual details.
Aside from that, I always marveled that a guy who sounded like the voice on the phone in those Peanuts cartoons could produce some of the most iconic 20th Century pop songs.